News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by cm2187 on Monday January 23, 2017 @03:58PM (#13465933)
That's akin to saying that someone has to scan all emails for potential crimes. So either gmail does it or the FBI does it.

Well, I think there is still a third option!

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by vageli on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:02PM (#13465989)
What might that option look like?
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by cm2187 on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:04PM (#13466006)
What I am discussing about with my correspondent is none of the business of the FBI or my email service provider, and if they want to read my conversation they need a warrant, exactly like they do for physical mail.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by smallnamespace on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:09PM (#13466047)
Couple of points:

- Someone is still scanning e-mails, except now it's a judge and/or lawyers rather than cops or business

- Moving things to the legal system imposes potentially very high friction costs, since your bank/email provider presumably has context about their relationship with you that the judge (or law enforcement) doesn't have. As we all know, context switches are inherently expensive.

- Emails aren't exactly the same as transmitting money, because reading emails tends to violate more of your privacy than the metadata about who you send money to. Also it's illegal to, say, send money to finance terrorists, so some checking has to happen at some level no matter what. You can say 'get a warrant', but if cops don't have access to data, and banks can't look at who you send money to, then how can cops have sufficient data to find probable cause under which to ask for a warrant? You're putting law enforcement in a situation where it's impossible to lawfully fulfill their duties to the public, unless your model is literally that judges always get all data without a warrant, and a court decides what's suspicious.

You might think that the incremental improvement in liberty is worth the friction cost of having lawyers and judges run everything, but I'm not sure everyone would agree.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by cm2187 on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:46PM (#13466362)
> Someone is still scanning e-mails, except now it's a judge and/or lawyers rather than cops or business

You are still starting from the assertion that every email has to be scanned for crime, that every financial transaction has to be investigated for fraud. I disagree with that. And where is the limit? Should the bank also check that the product you are trying to sell is compliant with the latest health & safety regulations and that you didn't violate environmental protection laws? The bank is potentially facilitating a crime if it isn't.

> Also it's illegal to, say, send money to finance terrorists

But it is not illegal to conspire to commit a terrorist attack by email or phone or mail?

> banks can't look at who you send money to

Banks always know who you send money to. Phone companies always know who you call. What banks do not need to know is why I am sending this money. What phone companies do not need to know is what I am discussing about.

> You're putting law enforcement in a situation where it's impossible to lawfully fulfill their duties to the public

Was it impossible to do their work before the internet when law enforcement had to get a warrant to open mail and tap phone lines?

> You might think that the incremental improvement in liberty is worth the friction cost of having lawyers and judges run everything

Again you are still stuck in the logic of either my phone company listens to my calls or the police listens to my calls. Well, neither unless they get a warrant. Same for my emails. Same for my mail. Same for my financial transactions. The content of my calls is none of the business of the phone company. The content of my emails is none of the business of my email provider. The reason for my transaction is none of the business of my bank.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by smallnamespace on Monday January 23, 2017 @05:03PM (#13466519)
Yes, I think it's fundamentally impossible to effectively prevent or prosecute certain types of crime without scanning financial metadata, such as funding of terrorist groups or cross-border fraud.

The model of 'wait until someone complains, then get a warrant, then use that data to prosecute' simply doesn't work in practice, and the article notes exactly why. For criminal networks, by the time the judicial gears have started running, the criminals are long gone with their ill-gotten profits. For terrorist enterprises, it's easy and cheap to create puppet companies or non-profits to take donations, and prosecuting terrorists after they've used the money to commit violence is not acceptable to society.

> Should the bank also check that the product you are trying to sell is compliant with the latest health & safety regulations and that you didn't violate environmental protection laws?

No, because you can effectively punish companies that violate health and safety regulations after the financial transaction takes place. For scammers, that's not true.

You might think that having these crimes is simply the price of liberty, but I think many people would disagree. I don't think the rhetorical strategy of denying there is a problem, and claiming that policing strategies from 30 years ago will fix all the problems, is a reasonable one.

> Was it impossible to do their work before the internet when law enforcement had to get a warrant to open mail and tap phone lines?

Yes, because now criminals aren't communicating with mail and phone lines, they're using the internet, which is a completely different beast. You can't run a business like you did 30 years ago and succeed. You can't make a movie like you did 30 years ago and expect to succeed. What makes you so confident and sure that wiretap laws from 30 years ago can be perfectly and successfully applied to the internet today?

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by mcbits on Monday January 23, 2017 @05:20PM (#13466658)
I don't think you can mold your argument so that it doesn't apply equally to searching everyone's closets for skeletons once a week without suspicion because that's the only way to root out the Jeffrey Dahmers of the world.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by smallnamespace on Monday January 23, 2017 @05:40PM (#13466838)
- In practice, we as a society value stopping fraud and terrorist funding quite a bit more than rooting out every last Jeffrey Dahmer

- Looking through financial metadata is a couple orders of magnitude less invasive than physically searching everyone's closet every week

All I'm saying here is there is actually a tradeoff between privacy and law-enforcement effectiveness. Of course we should think of ways to have both, but it is not always possible in every case. As engineers, that should be easy to understand.

If we're being honest with ourselves, we should admit that we're willing to pay a cost (perhaps even a substantial one) for greater privacy. We should then have a discussion about which costs we're willing to pay, for which particular forms of privacy, and how to get the most bang for our buck.

We should not simply pretend that the cost of upholding our liberal values is zero, as tempting as that might be rhetorically.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by Bjartr on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:02PM (#13467933)
Would you mind educating me as to when "we as a society" made the decision to shift away from valuing the privacy of an individual to the point that it is a foregone conclusion that we should eschew those liberties and implicitly throw away the protections of due process rather than improve and reform the judicial system whose inefficiency is the real bottleneck?

Yes, there are tradeoffs to be made, but existing due process, including warrants, is the legal manifestation of those very tradeoffs.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by drewmol on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:24AM (#13469226)
Specific to American Legislation, and for those who may be unfamiliar: look into the passing of the USA P.A.T.R.I.O.T Act passed shortly after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, a bill of over 2000 pages which was rushed through congress in span of a few days from finalization to ratification under the prosumtion of necessity to provide the tools to combat terrorism. It stripped away many powers of the judicial branch to provide oversight, and provisions intended to be 'temporary' have been continually extended by presidents (executive branch) on both sides of the aisle since. (edited: misspelled patriot acronym)
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by smallnamespace on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:39AM (#13469077)
I never posited that, and of course we should not throw away our liberties. I just happen to think that defending your liberties requires a healthy dose of realism about how the police and judicial system actually work. As difficult as that may be to accept, that also requires some level of trust in those institutions and in what the leaders of those institutions say.

When police or FBI say that current laws and processes are insufficient to deal with a changed environment and they need help, I've seen that the left tends to demonize them, question their motivations (like of course cops want to set up a surveillance state), and then give a hand-wavy argument that 'well, getting a warrant worked in the past, so it must work fine today'. Basically accusing cops of lying about having problems, or lying about needing new tools and processes.

That doesn't seem very fair, and it's certainly not a way to have a constructive discussion. I mean, these two statements are basically the same:

1. You can't any trust climate scientists, because of course all they want is to scare you into giving them more funding and power

2. You can't any trust cops and the intelligence services, because of course all they want is to scare you into giving them more funding and power

IMHO both these statements are false. Even though they're imperfect, our cops and intelligence agencies by and large try to do right, and it'd be better to understand challenges from their perspective and come up with innovative, privacy-protecting ideas that work, rather than to blindly accuse them of malice when they suggest something that we disagree with.

If you think people are doing things wrong, first try help them do right.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by abecedarius on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:47PM (#13468138)
Two elements of rhetoric here that I object to:

- "We as a society" claims, painting your opponent as out of touch with society. I'd say instead that the ecosystem of recent U.S. politics has been favorable to actors gaining power on those grounds.

- Equating opposing surveillance to pretending the costs of liberty are zero. I didn't see anyone else claim that above, though maybe I should go back and reread it all.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:10AM (#13468960)
> In practice, we as a society value stopping fraud and terrorist funding quite a bit more than rooting out every last Jeffrey Dahmer

You say "we as a society" but then posit something ridiculous. Regular everyday murderers kill orders of magnitude more Americans than terrorists. They are monsters of the same order and there are more of them. How is it that we have stood to tolerate them for centuries, but now this new threat (which is not actually new at all) suddenly requires a departure from our longstanding principles?

Terrorism isn't new, it isn't unique, it doesn't require an extraordinary response unlike that of every other category of bad in the world. It's just the boogey man du jour that has recently become highly profitable for a wide variety of fear mongers and demagogues.

Don't fear the terrorists. You're letting the terrorists win.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by caf on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:31AM (#13469047)
Regular everyday murderers kill orders of magnitude more Americans than terrorists.

Jeffrey Dahmer wasn't a regular everyday murderer, he was a serial killer - a category which does not kill orders of magnitude more Americans than terrorists, and a distinction which is entirely apropos in this discussion because unlike regular everyday murderers, serial killers are generally quite hard to identify with usual police investigatory methods.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @08:26PM (#13477593)
You're trying to narrow the category but the distinction you're trying to make isn't there. A huge proportion of the "regular everyday murderers" are committed by gang members in communities with the "snitches get stitches" ethos. As a consequence they go unsolved given the usual police investigatory methods.

A cynic might speculate that politicians care more about terrorism because gangs kill predominantly poor people while terrorists often kill bankers and government officials.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by anigbrowl on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:15PM (#13466110)
Investigating individual complaints of fraud as they come in in the old-fashioned way.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by jandrese on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:38PM (#13466287)
AKA the system that didn't work? By the time the report comes in the money is gone and so are the perps.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by problems on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:59PM (#13466485)
Yes, sometimes the best you can do without violating everyone's privacy is just the best you can do. You work with it. You lose sometimes, maybe you pay a percent or two extra for insurance to pay out in such cases of fraud, but you accept that it's better than the blatant privacy violation of the other systems.

To put it another way, just because terrorists could use unencrypted email to communicate doesn't mean we have to go and scan everyone's email for threats.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by pixelcloud on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:00PM (#13468466)
And to further this point. You address the root causes of these issues in government and society. Why is the debate "Should we take away more of peoples privacy?" and not "How can we stop things from happening that create reasons to remove privacy?".

The logic is basically this: Terrorists now are communicating over encrypted p2p systems (or any new tech)! we need to backdoor encryption standards. Then! we will defeat the Terrorists (once and for all).

Crime works in a similar fashion. The police will never "solve crime" no matter how much power they have to invade your privacy. They will become great at catching criminals though.

Typical humans!

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by anigbrowl on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:48PM (#13466378)
So try something else that's less intrusive. Get photos/fingerprints of people who pick up, educate WU employees in how scams work and train them to warm would-be transfer originators, require them to tell customers what percentage of transactions turn out to be fraudulent and that they have had to pay millions in fines for abetting them before they take anyone's money. It's not hard to come up with other ideas.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by jandrese on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:55PM (#13466456)
You want to put the onus of enforcement on Nigerian Western Union operators and police?

It's not like they let the money sit around in the branch. Once it appears they send in the street rat to pick it up and run. These scams aren't just two bit crooks, they were straight up organized crime. It is an industry, one of the most productive in some areas.

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by cm2187 on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:47PM (#13466368)
When your transaction is being investigated, your funds are usually blocked until the bank is satisfied you are compliant.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by mindcrime on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:34PM (#13467762)
Then so be it. None of this is in any way a justification for giving the State the power to trample on our right to privacy. There will always be crime. Why pretend otherwise in some ill-conceived effort to engineer the "perfect society"?
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by jandrese on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @11:44AM (#13472940)
Why even have police? I mean crime is going to happen right? And the cops just trample all over your rights. Why even bother having laws or society? It just kills your freedom.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by mindcrime on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:15PM (#13473291)
Why even have police?

Good question.

I mean crime is going to happen right?

Evidence suggests so.

And the cops just trample all over your rights.

Indeed.

Why even bother having laws or society?

Agreed, especially considering that most of what passes for "law" these days is just statutory nonsense which has nothing to with the law[1] in the more general sense.

It just kills your freedom

Agreed.

[1]: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html

Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by jandrese on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:45PM (#13475291)
Yeah! Go Internet Anarchist! Show those stuck up normies just how dumb they are for not wanting to be randomly killed by roving gangs of thugs!
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by mindcrime on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:24PM (#13475638)
Nice strawman.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by bbcbasic on Monday January 23, 2017 @08:11PM (#13467974)
Gmail do scan all emails for certain crimes. But I digress, sorry.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by zeroer on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:40PM (#13468376)
By "certain" you mean child porn, right? I can't think of any other crime that meets the two criteria that 1) it can be done over email and 2) detection can be reliably automated.
Re:Western Union admits to aiding wire fraud, to pay $586M by petre on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:42AM (#13469298)
This already sounds like Minority Report.