News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by jrockway on Thursday May 13, 2010 @09:24PM (#1346247)
I know this is a parody, but why do we, as a society, care about immigration status? We're all citizens of Earth.

If "an illegal" is obeying the law and contributing to society, they're already doing better than the 3.2% of "real Americans" in prison. So why bother them? Why do we even care?

Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by tptacek on Thursday May 13, 2010 @11:45PM (#1346488)
If you read the Stratfor guy's book, we're in a delusional blip of time where stuff like this can happen. 20-30 years from now, basic demographics are going to flip the equation on it's head; we'll be begging for Mexican immigrants simply to do the day-to-day work that we'll be too old to do. Add to that our lack of population density relative to other countries, our strategic control of the continent and both oceans, and our ability to absorb a constant influx of immigrant labor (and tax base) is a huge national asset.

In the meantime we'll just have to hope that Major League Baseball can right this (social, ethical, logistical, economic) wrong.

Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday May 13, 2010 @09:48PM (#1346296)
In all cases I've seen (besides outright bigotry, which this law is) the reason people care is because of one aspect of "obeying the law" that illegal aliens can't comply with: paying income taxes.

In a nutshell that's all governments care about most: pay your taxes and you are no longer a problem.

Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by tptacek on Thursday May 13, 2010 @11:47PM (#1346495)
People in lower income brackets pay very little of their income in actual income tax, and while being paid under the table also keeps them from contributing to payroll taxes, the fact that they aren't going to be claiming the benefits FICA allegedly pays for mitigates that. Meanwhile, they continue to drive whatever consumption taxes we set up --- and again, being in a lower income bracket, they pay disproportionately more in those taxes than we do.

I wouldn't be surprised to see reasonable arguments in either direction (positive or negative) about the economic impact of illegal immigration. I bet it's fuzzier than you think it is.

Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by skorgu on Thursday May 13, 2010 @09:59PM (#1346319)
Illegal immigrants don't pay income taxes but their employers do contribute payroll and social security payments. Not disagreeing at all, just clarifying for non-US readers; wehave a lot of distinct taxes.
Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by tptacek on Thursday May 13, 2010 @11:49PM (#1346497)
The allegation would be that most illegal immigrants are not getting W2 deductions on their wages --- that being part of the point of hiring them.
Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by jrockway on Friday May 14, 2010 @09:35AM (#1347273)
Not a lot different than my "contractor" friends that spend every waking second trying to figure out how not to pay all their 1099 taxes.
Re:Why All Americans Should Carry ID Papers by jrockway on Thursday May 13, 2010 @09:49PM (#1346300)
If they pay their income tax, they get deported. If they don't pay, they can stay (or maybe get deported).

The incentive structure is set up wrong.