Because cash you can spend somewhere else.
Suppose you like football. If the money is "student loans" then you can spend it by attending a school with a big fancy college football stadium and subsidized tickets for students. If the the money is cash then you can use it to go to that school instead of a less expensive one with no football stadium, or you can go to the less expensive school and use the money to buy NFL season tickets.
So when the money is student loans, people have only the first option and all the schools have to build big fancy football stadiums to attract students. But you can't do that on a per-student basis. And you can't directly buy college football tickets with student loan money but you can launder it through administration to subsidize them. So everybody who attends that school ends up paying for football even if all they really wanted was an education, and then people have to consider the quality of the school's football team when choosing schools instead of only the quality of their professors. It would have been better to have just let the students who like football use the money to buy NFL tickets.
And so on for twelve other categories of student loan money laundering colleges have to engage in to attract students.
> UBI also removes the advantage of centralized negotiating power that's beneficial in industries like healthcare. With Medicare or a private insurance company the $500 list price for doctor's exam can be negotiated down to $99.
There is no reason you can't use your UBI money to buy private insurance.
And the only reason the list price for those things is $500 is that everybody knows the scam. The buyer for the insurance company wants to look like a great negotiator to his boss, so the doctor's office claims everything costs five times as much as they actually want and the buyer gets to look like a big hero for whacking it down so much.
And in general insurance makes things cost more for the same reason colleges with fancy football stadiums are more expensive. People don't ask whether something is worth the cost when they're spending somebody else's money. If you're paying out of your own pocket, you ask if knowing the result of some test is really worth $1200 of your money. If the insurance company is paying for it, you run all the tests whether you need them or not.
If you have government or insurance pay for everything (and then pay everyone the same amount) the buyer still doesn't know which doctor provides the best care, but now doctors have the incentive to provide no more than the bare minimum care because they aren't allowed to charge any more for better quality/convenience/atmosphere for the same procedure.
I agree, but how does showing up with a wad of cash instead of a check from a student loan agency increase your negotiating power? Large number of international students today (Chinese and Saudi until recently) paid cash and yet had little say on football teams, new administrative buildings or spending in general. The university system just goes out and borrows whatever it feels like, the debt service is added to expenses.
UBI also removes the advantage of centralized negotiating power that's beneficial in industries like healthcare. With Medicare or a private insurance company the $500 list price for doctor's exam can be negotiated down to $99. With UBI it's the consumer against doctor's office, whch historically did not play out well due to massive information disadvantage.