News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clever "down for maintenance" page by m0th87 on Thursday May 13, 2010 @07:31PM (#1346044)
If a comedian worried about offending people, s/he wouldn't be funny. If Apple worried about alienating large swaths of the marketplace, it wouldn't have a rabid following.

If there weren't a "positive" effect of alienation, people wouldn't consciously cause it. Maybe it's a side-effect of good marketing. Or maybe it props up the sort of us vs. them mentality associated with cult followings. Or maybe I'm getting too philosophical, and everything I'm saying is bullshit.

Re:Clever "down for maintenance" page by hugothefrog on Thursday May 13, 2010 @07:51PM (#1346085)
Hah - I didn't intend to end 3/4 of my post with question marks. Or did I? ..ahem.

My comment was really a rhetorical question about the moral (not necessarily commercial - I'm not arguing that) appropriateness of taking (as you described) an alienating path.

I've read quite a few descriptions of marketing as being successful by causing unknown wants and needs. None of those descriptions really talk about 'us and them' as a concept.

[edit-minor typo]