Re:Show HN: iPad port of my sheet music app Etude
by dangrover on Thursday May 13, 2010 @07:09PM
(#1346008)
It goes at the speed of the music, depending on how long notes are held. I've been experimenting with that animation...it does seem kinda uncanny valley somehow
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: iPad port of my sheet music app Etude
by mcav on Thursday May 13, 2010 @08:55PM
(#1346197)
I noticed that too. I'm not sure if there's a better way to do it or not; as a piano player myself, it might seem more intuitive to me to have a visual indicator at each beat in the measure, and then just highlight each note (via color or something) as it's played. I think the reason it seems off is because it's so irregular, even though it does match with the music itself.
Kudos though, Etude looks great.
Re:Show HN: iPad port of my sheet music app Etude
by manvsmachine on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:49AM
(#1346737)
I'd suggest a combination of both mcav and cpr's suggestions. Highlight the notes themselves instead of the area around them. Drop the jumpy marker and replace it with a smoothly moving, constant speed vertical marker. It's a commonly recognized and understood element (used in pretty much any and every audio production / recording software). It also gives the viewer a better sense of the tempo. Remember, tempo can change drastically over the course of a song; the current marker doesn't demonstrate the difference between playing shorter notes at a slower tempo and longer notes at a faster tempo.
Re:Show HN: iPad port of my sheet music app Etude
by Entlin on Friday May 14, 2010 @04:57AM
(#1346906)
I agree, combining note highlighting and smooth moving marker would seem to be the best way to go.
It's probably best if the moving marker is a 1-inch-wide bar that is very subdued. In my head at least, this would work best.