Re:Why we should all have a basic income
by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 22, 2017 @06:03PM
(#13458190)
> From a business point of view, suddenly everyone has an extra $1000.
It's not "suddenly everyone has an extra $1000", it's "suddenly the average person with insurance is sicker". It's like what happens if you want to buy fire insurance in an area with a higher incidence of wildfires. The reason insurance costs more there isn't inflation.
> They were buying stuff from you until now, there's no reason not to try to drive the price up to see how much more you can charge now.
Except that you have competitors who are happy to take all your business by selling at the existing price which is already profitable.
> So if literally everyone has an extra $1000, nobody has an extra $1000.
If literally everyone has an extra $1000 then you must have printed the money, which isn't what anyone is proposing.
And even then is still not true, because printing $1000 for each person is still wealth redistribution from creditors to debtors.
It's not "suddenly everyone has an extra $1000", it's "suddenly the average person with insurance is sicker". It's like what happens if you want to buy fire insurance in an area with a higher incidence of wildfires. The reason insurance costs more there isn't inflation.
> They were buying stuff from you until now, there's no reason not to try to drive the price up to see how much more you can charge now.
Except that you have competitors who are happy to take all your business by selling at the existing price which is already profitable.
> So if literally everyone has an extra $1000, nobody has an extra $1000.
If literally everyone has an extra $1000 then you must have printed the money, which isn't what anyone is proposing.
And even then is still not true, because printing $1000 for each person is still wealth redistribution from creditors to debtors.