Re:Why we should all have a basic income
by nabla9 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @04:22PM
(#13457565)
Of course not.
For most people that $1000 is taken away by taxation and UBI is income neutral for them.
>Giving money/help selectively to those who need it right now (and can prove it, i.e. no job but looking for one) is still better than UBI.
No, it's not. If you don't believe me read what Milton Friedman wrote about subject. Friedman suggested UBI or negative income tax because they would not distort markets the way welfare programs do.
Social welfare programs create incentive traps where people have marginal effective tax rates as high as 80-90%. You work and your welfare drops accordingly. Here in Finland marginal effective tax rate in some cases is higher than 100%.
For most people that $1000 is taken away by taxation and UBI is income neutral for them.
>Giving money/help selectively to those who need it right now (and can prove it, i.e. no job but looking for one) is still better than UBI.
No, it's not. If you don't believe me read what Milton Friedman wrote about subject. Friedman suggested UBI or negative income tax because they would not distort markets the way welfare programs do.
Social welfare programs create incentive traps where people have marginal effective tax rates as high as 80-90%. You work and your welfare drops accordingly. Here in Finland marginal effective tax rate in some cases is higher than 100%.