Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by tggran on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:17AM
(#13454541)
This site has a list of repos with fast growth in their number of stars: http://gittrends.io/#/explore?page=1&language=All&domain=All.... The list seems to be based on the shape of the curve of stars growth.
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by nagasaki45 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @07:17AM
(#13454865)
One of the problems I see with stars on github is the extreme hype around new JS frameworks, which is especially noticable in GitTrends. These projects are indeed trendy, but when you try to choose a tool / technology stars become problematic. I'm not saying that the metric I propose is more "objective" in any sense, but in my subjective opinion it promotes better values for open source projects.
Moreover, please don't think that I only count commits and see the about page (http://www.krihelinator.xyz/about) for more details about the metric.
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by tggran on Sunday January 22, 2017 @07:30AM
(#13454896)
Yes, I agree, but I also think the most interesting comparisons are intra-ecosystem. It does not make sense to use stars to compare a JS framework with a Clojure one, for example
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by Vinnl on Sunday January 22, 2017 @04:12AM
(#13454382)
Maybe an algorithm that ranks based on number of unique contributors in the past month or so?
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by nagasaki45 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @05:59AM
(#13454649)
I agree, that's why the number of contributors in the last week have the most weight in the metric. See the about page (http://krihelinator.xyz/about) for more details.
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by ukyrgf on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:36AM
(#13454142)
Yeah but Free Code Camp can't honestly be 'trending' for two years straight.
Re:Show HN: GitHub trending alternative that ranks repos by ...
by the_rara_avis on Sunday January 22, 2017 @09:40AM
(#13455327)
It does because one of the getting started tutorials features a GIF that suggests newcomers star their repository.
From what I understand, creating an algorithm to reflect what is active/popular/well-supported and well-contributed, without creating the over-saturation/bubbling/reddit-like effect is hard to do, and doesn't necessarily get easier with a large data set.
I hope someone more clever than myself can come up with something, though!