News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s Not Just the Drug War (2015) by 0xcde4c3db on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:55AM (#13444188)
Gottschalk uses a term I'm unfamiliar with: "race liberals". Does anyone know what the definition or typical usage pattern of this term is? Is it specific to some particular academic field or political clique? I'm not finding very good examples with Google (which thinks that "race, liberals" and "race. Liberals" are good matches).
Re:It’s Not Just the Drug War (2015) by _delirium on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:27AM (#13444441)
It's a similar construction to "fiscal conservative" or "social liberal", i.e. in this case people who had liberal views on racial issues in the 1940s-70s debate over the civil-rights movement. I think this particular phrase is a bit idiosyncratic to Gottschalk, though. It's intended to give her a concise phrase that includes social liberals, conservatives who had liberal views on civil rights (common among northern conservatives at the time), etc., rather than having to constantly repeat a construction like "those who had liberal views on racial issues".
Re:It’s Not Just the Drug War (2015) by richmarr on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:04AM (#13444274)
> "...race liberals ran roughshod over deep concerns expressed by other liberals and some experts on crime and punishment that the quest for more proceduralism untethered to substantive goals in criminal justice would yield a more punitive criminal justice system"

Outside the actual meaning intended for 'race liberals' it does seem like a case of labelling with the intent to paint a non-neutral narrative. The 'race liberals' ran roughshod. The other liberals concerns were deep, and supported by experts, and the proceduralism was apparently not tethered to any goals.

This paragraph at least seems more fiction than non-fiction.

Re:It’s Not Just the Drug War (2015) by Tloewald on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:31AM (#13444478)
The sentence is a little tough to unpack but it's saying that emphasizing procedure (rules) with a focus on race rather than improving criminal justice more broadly could yield a more punitive system. It's describing a difference of opinion, and this opinion seems reasonable.

I assume a "race liberal" is someone who is liberal with respect to race just as a "social conservative" might be pro union and pro welfare but anti gay and anti abortion.

Re:It’s Not Just the Drug War (2015) by richmarr on Saturday January 21, 2017 @06:14AM (#13449665)
> ...emphasizing procedure (rules) with a focus on race rather than improving criminal justice more broadly could yield a more punitive system... I assume a "race liberal" ...

I'm not aware anyone in this thread is having difficulty 'unpacking' the sentence, or extrapolating the broad meaning of the term 'race liberal'.

If you read the parent's comment in a more generous frame of mind you'll realise that they were probably interested in exactly how this term has been applied in the past.

My own comment was regarding the way the author presented a narrative, using labels without describing who she was actually talking about, criticising their actions without describing what they actually did.

This narrative proclaims that a group did something without evidence or even goals, against the deep wishes of others, including experts.

Does it seem likely that they didn't have goals (after all the qualifier 'substantive' is deeply subjective)?

Does it seem likely that all the experts were opposed?

Does it seem likely that only the opposing side had deep concerns?