News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Do I Declare a Function Pointer in C? by paulnechifor on Thursday January 19, 2017 @03:07PM (#13439041)
The "spiral rule" doesn't work all the time. See this previous HN comment by stephencanon: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12775862 .

Also this comment by Linus Torvalds (copy pasted because I don't know how to link to Google+ comments):

> I don't think that works. It breaks trivially for consecutive [] or * cases, something that he carefully didn't have in his examples.

> So the examples were made up to make it look like it's a spiral, but type parsing is about precedence, not about spirals. It so happens that the higher-precedence operators ([] and ()) are on the right-hand side, which is why it "works" to start on the right.

> And it doesn't explain why

> typedef int (fn_t[][2])(void);

> is ok, but

> typedef int (fn_t[2][])(void);

> is not.

> "Spirals"? I don't think so.

Re:How Do I Declare a Function Pointer in C? by dnquark on Thursday January 19, 2017 @05:35PM (#13440107)
All these years I assumed that the 'spiral rule' and 'right-left rule' (linked from the stephencanon comment above, and also described in my second link) are two ways to describe the same algorithm, but, reading closely, they aren't! I guess 'spiral rule' is a stickier name, which is why it's something that people remember even though it's janky.
Re:How Do I Declare a Function Pointer in C? by a_t48 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @06:33PM (#13440455)

    typedef int *(**fn_t[][2])(void);
is ok, but

    typedef int *(**fn_t[2][])(void);
is not.

(fixed formatting?)