"best students" meaning those who are eager to learn and have supportive family situations. Teachers can't do it on their own.
Re:State's bad teachers rarely get fired
by yummyfajitas on Thursday May 13, 2010 @01:25PM
(#1344905)
Students who knew a lot going into 3'rd grade and still knew a lot coming out of 3'rd grade will not have a high derivative. Thus, merit based pay would reward their teacher the same as if students knew very little going into 3'rd grade and knew very little coming out.
The only way I can see to game derefr's system is to pack your class with students who used to have bad family situations, but who's family situations have recently improved. I rather doubt there are enough students in that situation to pack many classes.
Rather than the current No Child Left Behind policy of regression to the mean, this would assign the most "learning-intensive" teachers to the students most in need of learning, and assign the students who self-study or are otherwise pre-informed to teachers who are more "lenient", likely diving further into interesting sidebars and tangents. Both groups would be better off for it.