News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook’s Zuckerberg sues to force land sales by smallnamespace on Thursday January 19, 2017 @01:52AM (#13433689)
Identifying one edge case doesn't really prove an argument. Net wealth is not a perfect metric, but is probably the best one we have.

You can be sure 95%+ of brain surgeons have paid off all their student debts and have a lot more wealth than a homeless guy, considering their median salary is $395k per year.

Re:Facebook’s Zuckerberg sues to force land sales by matt4077 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @05:16AM (#13434583)
Those wealth statistics really are dodgy. Another edge case: you're earning so little that you don't save, but spend it all on food/housing/etc. Now your country's economy takes off and you suddenly earn 20% more. You're still spending it all, enjoying much better and healthier food. To those statistics, nothing changed.

Net income is a much better metric than wealth.

Re:Facebook’s Zuckerberg sues to force land sales by refurb on Thursday January 19, 2017 @09:03AM (#13435793)
One edge case? Look at the debt levels in the US! There is a huge chunk of the population that has a negative net worth, mostly due to mortgage debt.

Is it fair to say all those people are poorer than people in India who have a few dollars to their name?

Re:Facebook’s Zuckerberg sues to force land sales by smallnamespace on Thursday January 19, 2017 @10:53AM (#13436710)
Well, show me a perfect metric that doesn't have similar edge cases?

For example, income has its own issues -- a retiree can have little income but a big retirement fund to draw down.

In an ideal world, you'd probably measure something like current net wealth + discounted expected future earnings, and maybe use PPP instead of GDP, except now you're trying to measure two things accurately instead of one, and making guesses about the future too.