News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LimeWire Crushed in RIAA Infringement Suit by tptacek on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:20PM (#1343050)
If you know that your users are infringing copyrights, as Limewire surely does, and you facilitate that copyright infringement, as Limewire arguably does by providing P2P software principally to copyright infringers (as does seems empirically to be the case), and your product has little other purpose outside of copyright infringement (unlike, say, BitTorrent by itself), and you receive direct financial benefit from the actions of infringers, as Limewire does by charging ~$35 for their software, then you are exposed to a bunch of different vectors for indirect copyright infringement.

This is not a particularly complicated legal area, except to the extent that it necessarily skirts a bunch of grey areas in copyright law.

Re:LimeWire Crushed in RIAA Infringement Suit by qeorge on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:25PM (#1343170)
" your product has little other purpose outside of copyright infringement"

That's the killer right there. LimeWire needed to show a fair use of its product, and failed to do so.