> I'm going to dodge the breaking changes discussion, since it's a huge tangent,
How is it a tangent? One of the biggest reasons to want exhaustiveness checking is to avoid the even uglier problem of "compiling but semantic changing" changes.
> I greatly dislike _breaking_ changes and want languages that make it possible to avoid them
It seems you are only talking about disliking breaking changes that cause your program not to compile whole totally disregarding the danger of changes that compile but change semantics.
As respectfully as possible, that seems backwards to me.
> All I meant to do was point out that exhaustiveness checks are not without their tradeoffs.
And all I meant to do was point out that lack of exhaustiveness checks is not without its tradeoffs. :)
> I was visualising something like
OK then. We're in agreement on that point. This is what Clojure has in it's destructuring syntax, and, as I said, it's great.