The skeptic inside me says, who the hell are these guys anyway? And how do I know they will act responsibly? And even if they attempt to act responsibly how do we know anything will come of it in a sub-optimal situation (sub-optimal in my point of view because they have little experience, no mentors, and don't have to answer to anyone. I don't think a great amount of experience is necessary but when combined with the other two it just doesn't look good.)
Also, it just seems like this system is ripe for abuse. If I just want 50,000 bucks it seems like I can use Kickstarter to mobilize people around some fake or inflated cause, do little to no work, and pocket the money.
No offense to Kickstarter, I participated in "New York Makes a Book"!
[EDIT] Also, I agree with pretty much everything you said. All of that can and will happen in the best case scenario, but how likely is it?
Hopefully they'll pick something like YC for their source of knowledge. Or they might crowd source that too, no telling. Already people are offering them fat pipes, infrastructure expertise and so on.
They're currently pulling in $3500 per hour, it is accelerating rather than slowing down. If they hit a feedback loop (if that isn't already happening) this will be the start-up story of the year. By some measures it already is.
edit: they just picked up another $2K donation, $55,429 now, that's a 10% increase in about an hour and half.
The harm will be if they fail. Even if they ship something in the next 6 months I'll be really impressed.
re: 2: that's the worrying bit. But there is nothing lost by trying, we'll all learn from this.
If they fail, then we can analyze why they failed. If they succeed there will be a lot of attempts to copy this success. There already will be I believe.
Something new is happening here, crowdsourced funding on a relatively significant scale.
And I think you could safely add a 0 to your estimate of how much money they'll end up with, which will give them several things: Investors will see the concept as 'validated' by the target audience before they've even written a single line of code. And big name companies with resources and experience will fall over each other by next Friday to have their name associated with this effort.
If they're smart they sell their skins dear and get a reputable investor on board for the expertise they miss and the networking factor.
The excess money will give them runway and extra clout during negotiations.