Thanks for the pointer. I tried desultorily to get a (net-)look at the Gow text, but no dice. I'll have to leave it to some weekend/vacation time to chase sources.
It's curious that the A.E.H. vinegar does not get wider circulation. My copy of Matthew Parris' Scorn only features a couple of harmless barbs (one the 'malt/Milton' line). There are some scraps over at http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alfred_Edward_Housman , and here http://www.lrb.co.uk/v29/n13/frank-kermode/nothing-for-ever-...
(Also, a passing appreciation by Chesterton, a guide I trust, here http://wikilivres.info/wiki/Autobiography_%28Chesterton%29/C...)
"Nature, not content with denying to Mr — the faculty of thought, has endowed him with the faculty of writing."
The name was left blank in the original, but was intended to be filled in and used when a suitable subject should turn up.
Apparently, after he died, they found notebooks in his office that he had filled with long elaborate, witty, hurtful insults -- aimed at nobody in particular. When he wrote a review, he would tweak the pre-fab insults as needed and voila. A sick, twisted person, but fascinating. (If you're really curious, check out Tom Stoppard's The Invention of Love.)