News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by ars on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @08:08PM (#1342716)
It's their own fault for being idiots and not actually screening it in cinemas. People who download on bittorrent will almost never pay - they are not your customers. Ignore them.

Your customers will pay, but only if they can. It only screened in a few cities, so it's their own fault for making it impossible for people to pay them.

The movie business is doing really well right now. bittorrent has not had the slightest effect. If your are not making money on a movie it's your own fault - not bittorrent.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by pl0nk on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:14AM (#1343475)
> It's their own fault for being idiots and not actually screening it in cinemas

Do you think they really just forgot to screen it?

Or could it instead just be that it's difficult to get broad distribution without a gigantic budget and/or sequel to a safe franchise? Somehow I imagine it was harder for them to get screenings than it was for Iron Man 2.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by ars on Thursday May 13, 2010 @06:03PM (#1345858)
This film was talked about as a prime Oscar candidate for months before the Oscars.

They really can't get distribution for an Oscar film? I doubt that. I think they just miscalculated the timing.

Or they could have sold DVDs before the Oscars. People would have bought them once they won.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by matwood on Thursday May 13, 2010 @08:57PM (#1346200)
I understand your point and agree with you. There was a movie not long ago that had just came to video. I checked the xbox and I couldn't rent it, only buy the SD version. So I check netflix steaming, not available. I check netflix movies and it's on a wait to rent. I can see why people go to P2P networks after I tried many ways to get the movie legally.

I still haven't seen the movie since after all that I didn't feel like watching it then anyways.

And don't even get me started on the impossible to skip commercials!

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by pmccool on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:18PM (#1343041)
By the same reasoning, it's my fault if I leave the door unlocked and my house gets burgled. Maybe so, but it doesn't make burglary OK, not in that case, nor in general.

Maybe they should distribute differently, maybe not. That doesn't excuse illicit downloading.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by ars on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:34PM (#1343080)
Missed my point.

The piracy is not their fault.

What is their fault is that they didn't make "enough" money, and now they need some extra from the pirates.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by pmccool on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:18PM (#1343160)
Whether their business decisions to date have been good, bad or indifferent has no bearing on whether it's right or wrong to now sue illicit downloaders.

Would it really be any different if they had made a fortune? I think not.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by ars on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:32PM (#1343186)
From the article:

"Locker" first leaked onto the web more than five months before its U.S. release and was a hot item in P2P circles after it won six Oscars in March. Despite the accolades, the film grossed only about $16 million in the U.S.

"Only $16 million" is their own fault, not the fault of the "P2P circles" as implied.

They were idiots and now they are trying to blame pirates for the lost business, when actually the pirates have no impact on profits.

It's not right or wrong to sue - it's stupid.

Re:Hurt Locker Producers To Sue Thousands of Piraters by pl0nk on Thursday May 13, 2010 @02:22AM (#1343489)
> If your are not making money on a movie it's your own fault - not bittorrent

Are you implying that theft is not wrong as long as you're still making a profit?