Re:Announcing Rust Language Server Alpha Release
by flukus on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:57AM
(#13425482)
I'm not sure how the GPL effects anything here. This is a local service, not an internet service. And the GPL doesn't cover the output of GCC at all. This also doesn't actually produce the end binaries.
Re:Announcing Rust Language Server Alpha Release
by Asooka on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:51AM
(#13425703)
It's not about the GPL. Historically, RMS has opposed any effort to make intermediate outputs of GCC available (e.g. the AST, type information, or even having a stable plugin API). On the basis that it would then be used to build closed-source products that use GCC as a service, rather than those products contributing to GCC. It might have been prompted by earlier efforts by Apple to make an Objective-C compiler built on GCC that isn't GPL-licensed, which obviously ran foul of the GPL. Ironically, that's why Apple invested in clang and why today we have the rich clang/llvm ecosystem.
When every language and every editor supports this protocol, who's going to want to use GCC for anything, when it's as closed (and thus relatively useful) as a brick?