Re:Obama Commutes Bulk of Chelsea Manning’s Sentence
by hackinthebochs on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:46PM
(#13423341)
I agree with you. I don't have a clear opinion of Snowden. The point was just that those who try to claim he was just blowing the whistle and therefore shouldn't be prosecuted or pardoned are missing the point of whistleblowing with respect to legal protections.
Am I saying I think it's outright justified? No, because I'm honestly not sure. I am however sure that it's not as black and white as 'legal' vs 'illegal' when it comes to whistleblowing because the extra infromation helps us establish a context and understand a sense of scale of the wrongdoing, for example.
edit: Here's an example: It's probably not illegal that the 'official' estimates of civilian deaths in the Iraq war were likely far lower than the reality. Assume for the sake of discussion that this was intentional. Having a better understanding the more realistic magnitude of civilian deaths helps the public understand the realities of such wars and helps them make more informed decisions on whether they're comfortable with the actions of their government. It changes the context of the Iraq war and may go from 'we were justified in doing it' to 'it wasn't worth it' for some of the voting public.