News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by vectorpush on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @06:49PM (#13422680)
This post is a quintessential example of why blockchain discussions are met with negativity. Your response to criticism is to castigate the critics as unimaginative and averse to "out group" technologies rather than counter the criticism with substance. It's also telling that you suggest people use their imagination to find uses for blockchains; no other technology has such backwards expectations. When you start with a solution and have to brainstorm imaginative ways to discover a problem that fits your solution, you know you're dealing with a cargo-cult instead of an effective tool.

> I've recently had conversations with companies working on solving two big problems in large media buying agencies - bot-based fraud, and auditability of programmatic trading. These problems are being solved using the bitcoin blockchain.

How is the bitcoin blockchain solving these problems? Please offer some kind of details or explanation. I could be wrong, but I'm betting that you're going to offer an example of how the blockchain could, in theory, maybe solve some of these problems but there are practical barriers to implementation and no real solution to be seen. That is exactly what creates a negative response towards blockchains, big talk and nothing to show for it. Cryptocurrency is literally the only thing that blockchains have been demonstrated to be useful for yet we're constantly bombarded with claims that blockchains are going to solve countless problems and it never pans out.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by theamk on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @04:59PM (#13421780)
> Unfortunately the comments are a pile-on of negativity, rather than a discussion of possibilities.

I don't think that how the community is supposed to work. HN is all about discussion of existing content. It is simply a bad form to go to discussion of "blockchan for big banks" article and start talking about "blockchain for ad networks".

Yes, maybe someone out there is making something where blockchain is genuinely a right technology; if you find such a project, submit it to HN and there may be actual positive comments on the blockchain idea.

Or even better: write a blog post about real-life problems which are best being solved by the bitcoin blockchain, and submit it. I am sure people will read it with interest! (I am not being sarcastic here -- I am genuinely interested about useful bitcoin applications)

Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by acdha on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @04:17PM (#13421296)
This is an odd way to criticize Patrick because it sounds you basically agree with him. Most of the blockchain boostery I've seen has been some combination of inefficient wheel reinvention, unworkable at scale, or an investment scam. The fact that there is the possibility of someone eventually doing something of real value with it doesn't change that or invalidate people objecting to the hype.
Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by sametmax on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @04:47PM (#13421627)
I'll +1 this. Dismissing the block-chain concept because the current implementations are not good replacement pour our best existing techs is like saying to not investigate electrical powered transportations because the solar plane projects we tried sucked.
Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by davidgerard on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @06:34PM (#13422568)
I think dismissing it because the current implementations are still startlingly awful after several years, with really obvious feasibility problems for their posited use cases, is fair enough really.

At this point the burden of proof really is pretty much entirely on the blockchain advocates. Bring a technically feasible use case to the table.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by detaro on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @04:53PM (#13421687)
I think most people here pretty clearly see that blockchains can be useful. But tons of relatively unsuccessful projects or worse, projects with grand claims and no details and evidence behind it cause widespread skepticism against new projects that don't clearly argue why they don't fit the pattern. Serious blockchain projects have a lot of "allies" that make them look pretty bad there.

Projects that clearly fit the pattern of good use cases get a lot less flak than startups or initiatives that do further out things and don't talk about details.

Unclear definitions (e.g. is a distributed ledger without expensive proof-of-work a blockchain or not?) are another issue.

Re:Ask HN: Why is the community so negative towards blockcha... by dang on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @06:01PM (#13422330)
Please don't make up generalizations about the HN community to score rhetorical points in an argument. That's never substantive.

Also, that bit about Patrick was needlessly personal. He has the same right to offer an opinion as anybody else does, and your 'royalty' bit is just posturing.

If you want to teach us something about how to be more imaginative, that's great, but the best way to do so is simply to convey information.