Re:Did Pixar accidentally delete Toy Story 2 during producti...
by Arizhel on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @03:35PM
(#13420930)
You're talking about big commercial planes. Yes, you can alter procedures here and attempt to prevent the same thing from happening again.
Not in general aviation. You're not going to get all the Cessna 172 owners to modify some part of their plane to make it better and avoid some incident where some yahoo private pilot did something dumb and crashed. It's hard enough just getting privately-owned aircraft to be properly serviced. Many of them are many decades old and quite primitive. You're not going to improve "the whole system", the HCI, etc. in some airplane made in 1940 or whenever.
Finally, attributing an incident to "pilot error" doesn't automatically mean that there weren't contributing factors or that things couldn't be done better.
For example, the first fatal 747 crash, the Lufthansa coming down upon departure from Nairobi, happened almost certainly because the flight crew did not extend the leading edge flaps. Clear case of pilot error. If that response had been it, it would have happened again (in fact, it did happen at least twice before, but at lower altitude airports where the aircraft performance was enough for the crew to depart without accident).
Instead, it was acknowledged that the whole system could be improved, and Boeing put in a take-off configuration warning.
Similarly, AF 347 over the Atlantic - sure, you can argue that the pilot in the right seat should not have pushed the stick forward, and that it was entirely his fault, case closed. But maybe one can, instead, improve the whole system, the HCI, etc.
Edit: typo