News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by lwhi on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:24AM (#13417249)
I'm confused why my comment has been downvoted.

Theresa May was not voted into government.

Only 52% of (72.2%) of the population voted for Brexit.

Quite a disappointing response.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by NetStrikeForce on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:32AM (#13417325)
Further proof many, many people don't understand democracy and think you're not allowed a voice.

People, democracy is not the tyranny of the majority. Quite the opposite actually.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by ohstopitu on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:48AM (#13417435)
how does democracy protect the minority? (not saying the minority does not have a voice, but how does it help, if they'll always be voted out?)

And if so (and this being a political thread) - Trump being elected is totally legit even though he got less votes (as he was voted by the majority in more than half the states) ?

Asking as an outsider - I just feel like everytime the popular opinion does not get voted in - there's an "justified" outcry (but if the majority had won - and there was an outcry by the minority - that's them being childish/not respecting democracy etc.)

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by NetStrikeForce on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:55AM (#13417486)
> how does democracy protect the minority? (not saying the minority does not have a voice, but how does it help, if they'll always be voted out?)

With separation of powers and the rule of law.

> And if so (and this being a political thread) - Trump being elected is totally legit even though he got less votes (as he was voted by the majority in more than half the states) ?

1- Everywhere I've lived in, my vote has had less power than the average of the state / region. I'm OK with that because otherwise all policies will only favour the overpopulated areas.

2- I don't know all the US election details, but apparently you've got a big issue with corruption that in this case reflects on gerrymandering.

3- If the situation was the opposite, Hillary winning despite less votes, I guess you wouldn't consider it legit? Don't answer me, that's easy; answer internally to yourself. Be sincere.

4- Your problem with Trump is that your "left" candidate is so to the right, that there's no room for human decency at her right. Just think about it, what's a more right-wing policy that doesn't go against climate change, equality/equity, worker's rights, military intervention, radicalisation of your police force, for profit prison system, stupid healthcare system, ... Should I keep going?

> Asking as an outsider - I just feel like everytime the popular opinion does not get voted in - there's an "justified" outcry (but if the majority had won - and there was an outcry by the minority - that's them being childish/not respecting democracy etc.)

There are always outcries when there's a strong division on a topic. We need to make sure our values stand every single time, whether our opinion wins or we loses.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by JohnStrange on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @11:57AM (#13419051)
It is not the tyranny of the majority, because a modern democracy protects and respects minorities, and the concerns of the majority are also into account. At least, that's how it should be.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by NetStrikeForce on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:05AM (#13425515)
Yes, in an ideal world.

However, "modern democracies" like Switzerland implement tyranny:

http://www.thelocal.ch/20160609/immigrant-family-denied-swis...

http://www.thelocal.ch/20170109/annoying-anti-cow-bell-campa...

(There are more sources for both, in case you don't trust this one)

Direct democracy is good, but we still don't seem to know how to implement it right or make a responsible use of it.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by JohnStrange on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @08:20AM (#13426098)
My suggestion to make direct democracy (plebiscite) work is to turn it into a mild form of technocracy. You'd have to pass an easy test made of a small random selection of Q&A's about a limited number of published facts similar to the theoretical part of drivers license tests, before you can cast your vote. So participation would require some effort and some dedication, though not any higher education or a lot of time investment.

This suggestion is unpopular among people who deny that there are facts and reality. These people exist both on the left (e.g. `social constructivism about science') and the right (e.g. recent trends among some Trump supporters) side of the political spectrum. Anybody who has no trouble with reality and has passed a drivers license should have no problems with it, though.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by NetStrikeForce on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:57AM (#13427865)
I don't think it does matter though.

Clever, wise and motivated people can also be arseholes and vote against you having local passport because you usually wear a tracksuit, are vegan or think cowbells not right.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by SixSigma on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:44AM (#13417407)
> Theresa May was not voted into government.

She was voted into government by her party, just like the leaders of every UK government.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by Noseshine on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:33AM (#13417330)
The point is there WAS a vote. A democratic vote. I'm looking at it from the outside and don't care either way - except that the way some very vocal ones of the so-called "remainers" dislike democracy and voting as soon as they don't get what they want disgusts me. Remember your attitude when some day - inevitably - it will be the other way around, you won a vote and the other side comes up with the same arguments.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by matthewmacleod on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:48AM (#13417444)
I don't think that's a fair assessment of the situation.

Yes, there was a referendum – but it wasn't a good one. It was advisory only – i.e. not binding – there was a narrow margin, no minimum turnout or majority requirements, and no concrete plan which was being voted on, or even any set of proposals from government. Two of the four countries in the UK voted to remain in the EU.

It think it's wholly reasonable to question a decision of such huge magnitude being made on the basis of a referendum in those circumstances.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by raesene6 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:02AM (#13417544)
However the majority of the people who voted (and remember here that the turnout was higher than most UK elections) voted to exit which clearly included border controls.

Border controls cannot be achieved without leaving the single market, so if we're honouring the democratic process this is the only possible path.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by gpderetta on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:20AM (#13417698)
The was no reference to border control in the referendum ballot.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by raesene6 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:28AM (#13417786)
it was a key stated pledge of the leave campaign, so unless you were watching some other referendum campaign the suggestion that border control had nothing to do with it is disingenuous at best.

In case anyone wants to argue that immigration wasn't a key part of the leave campaign... https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jun/27/eu-referend... a key pledge related to immigration directly and another was closely associated

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by Chestofdraw on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:56AM (#13418015)
> it was a key stated pledge of the leave campaign

Which leave campaign? There was a few of them and they didn't give a consistent message. None actually have any power to implement anything so how can they make pledges anyway?

Also, that link has the picture of the bus as the first image... a 'pledge' completely based on lies that was dropped literally minutes after the vote.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by raesene6 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:14AM (#13418164)
Let me ask you a question. Do you honestly believe that a big part (if not the key part) of the leave campaign (pick any one you like) wasn't about immigration and border control?
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by Chestofdraw on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:40AM (#13418393)
I'll tell you what, we can talk about the efficacy of the various leave campaigns when the NHS gets its 350 million a day and we have 'Sovereignty'.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by raesene6 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @11:18AM (#13418739)
I note that I'm afraid you didn't even attempt to answer my extremely straightforward question.

See I'm not a brexiter/leaver/whatever (Personally I think it's a terrible idea), but it's blindingly obvious to me that a lot of leave voters (maybe even the vast majority) thought the main issue was immigration and that Mrs May had a choice either exit the single market, or basically ignore the result of the referendum, she chose the former and not the latter.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by gpderetta on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:00PM (#13419071)
Soft brexit (i.e. EEA-like access) plus spend the next 10 years figuring out a better exit deal would have been an option.

UK spent 40 year entangling with the EU, disentangling cleanly in 2 years is a pipe dream.

It is still a possibility though; declaring for hard brexit could very well be a negotiating tactic (as in 'nothing left to lose') as May hinted to the possibility of a transitional agreement.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by raesene6 on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:49PM (#13419497)
I entirely agree the 2 year timeline is massively unrealistic (downside to something being written in a treaty agreement with no intention of it ever being excercised)

The challenge for me is that soft-brexit is basically no brexit 'cause EEA access == sign-up to the four fundamental freedoms and accept the primacy of EU law, which seems to cover most of the things that the leave campaign wanted to get rid of.

As you say this could well be a negotiating tactic though, and no-one will really know until they start the negotiations. I think it's entirely possible that once the details are fleshed out people might seek to change it.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by gpderetta on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @01:03PM (#13419626)
Soft brexit would only be a transitional state, with a set timeline or undefined. The hard brexiters would grumble at the former and be completley against the latter though.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by gpderetta on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:16AM (#13418180)
Is it the same article that claims that the leave campaign also promised access to the single market and that reports that the foreign secretary declared that 'the leave campaign had made “contradictory” and “mutually incompatible” promises to the British people'?
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by kamjam on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:32AM (#13417817)
Maybe you've misunderstood how democracy works with a dictatorship. Just because your "side" lost the vote does not mean you cave in and blindly follow down a blind alley.

By your reasoning, the other opposition parties (Labour, Liberal Democrats et al) should just sit idly by and not question or argue against any Tory policies for that term of Government?

I agree with you that the vote has been cast, the UK is leaving the EU. But to state people are not allowed to have a voice on the terms of leaving is naive at best. Had the result of the vote been the other way (48% leave, 52% remain) would be be having a "hard remain" and telling the leavers to shut up?

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by gaius on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:18AM (#13418198)
Maybe you've misunderstood how democracy works with a dictatorship. Just because your "side" lost the vote does not mean you cave in and blindly follow down a blind alley

But that is exactly what Remain would expect Leave to do, had Remain won, and everyone knows it.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by kamjam on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @07:25PM (#13422916)
When the vote is as close add it was, there is no high ground. It's a win/loss by a tiny majority. If remain had won I would like to think that people would have had enough sense to know that almost half the population is disgruntled and done something to make them happier instead of throwing insults everytime "they complained".

I guess no one will truly now know.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by sandbags on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:39AM (#13417374)
Yes there was a vote. But it was a vote on a very ambiguous set of terms that was also an advisory vote, not a binding vote. This vote has been taken by an unelected Prime Minister serving out a term won on a mandate to protect UK interests in Europe. The current PM's actions are quite illegitimate.
Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by SixSigma on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:45AM (#13417412)
Which election had "I want David Cameron as PM" on the ballot?

I only remember having the option to vote in parliamentary elections for my local MP.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by sandbags on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:58AM (#13417509)
On the leadership of the party I concede, strictly, your point. We don't vote for a PM, although clearly people knew who they were voting to be the PM.

But the government was elected with a manifesto commitment to protect our interests in Europe and hold a referendum. It was not, to my knowledge, invested with a mandate to act on that referendum in the way that it is doing.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by misnome on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:36AM (#13417853)
Almost as though we don't directly get to elect the people who administer the whole thing.

Sounds a bit like the EU, but we all know[1] how that's a completely different out-of-control unelected bureaucracy[2].

[1] Have been told

[2] The EU parliament doesn't count, for vague reasons that change every time you hear it.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by Noseshine on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:45AM (#13417411)
You can twist and turn it any way you like, there WAS a vote, it was democratic, and you just keep complaining and whining about democracy when you don't like the outcome.

  The current PM's actions are quite illegitimate.
If that is so go to the courts. Otherwise whatever you say is just an empty bag of hot air.

Of course, you won't do that - because you know very well the current UK government is perfectly legitimate.

And "brexit" was voted for by the people. People like you only start complaining when they dislike the result - or please show me your similar complains when the result was to your liking, because there always are people who abstain. Only votes from people who vote count, what a huge surprise.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by sandbags on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:56AM (#13417489)
Why do you have to take such a tone? Can we not disagree and argue without adhominem attacks?

Your argument is a fallacy. In any division there are going to be those who agree and disagree with the outcome. Of course the people who get what they "wanted" don't argue against it. But they also shouldn't argue against the legitimacy of those who don't to continue to argue their point. That is the difference here.

Yes, there was a vote on an advisory referendum that had not specific details about what the outcome should be. What does that make legitimate?

If Theresa may had decided that to leave the EU we had to go to war with Europe, would that be legitimised by the vote?

This argument is about the terms of any such approach and how to legitimise those.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by misnome on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:42AM (#13417891)
> If that is so go to the courts

They did. The court sided against the government. They appealed to the supreme court, whom we are currently awaiting a judgement from.

Re:Theresa May: UK must leave European single market by sandbags on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:58AM (#13417514)
I will add that there are two current legal challenges and I suspect there will be more.