Re:How Should We Donate $53,000 of xkcd Book Profits?
by jodrellblank on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @02:15PM
(#1341760)
If the measure is "donate to the cause that will benefit the most people" (which the inclusion of "will benefit 99% of people" suggests it is) then pulling apart "how many people will benefit" is hardly a nitpick of a completely inconsequential detail - it's a rebuke of the main detail.
For all de Grey's antiaging speculation, Dean Kamen's external combustion water purifier has the potential to benefit poor people who die young this year, not rich people who live a long time 25+ years from now. On the "where should we donate money now" question, de Grey's ideas are very distant with no clear paths to their realization.
And if you include speculative future technologies then Eliezer Yudkowsky's arguments for pushing AI development seem fundamentally more compelling than de Grey's argument for pushing antiaging research. Not that I can ever find specific Eliezer writings when I want to link to them :/
However, the point is MOST EVERYONE dies from something that's a result of getting older, and they'll benefit from age related research.
Most cancers even can't actually progress until older ages, as younger peoples' immune systems are so much better they typically fight off the disease.
Here's a pretty good TED talk on it. http://www.ted.com/talks/aubrey_de_grey_says_we_can_avoid_ag...