There's a economically solid argument to pay people to sit at home and not commit crime, start riots, devalue property by being homeless, or anything else vast numbers of people with no options currently do. Paying for someone's apartment and living expenses is FAR cheaper than the economic value lost by them devaluing property and tying up Emergency Services.
Newark, NJ causes a lot of harm to taxpayers who are forced to funnel resources to it. As far as I'm aware, bandits from Newark do not generally stage raids into Hoboken to steal resources from the productive folks living there.
Can you provide a back of the envelope calculation suggesting how an economically solid argument might work?
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/mar/...
That was minus 4 years worth of inflation and even then, if you take the most optimistic homeless numbers versus the most pessimistic housing numbers, it's still only a few hundred more. Frankly I'd much rather my tax dollars went to that than a ton of other things we blow way more money on.
You're just comparing two different versions of (a).
Anyway addressing that point, putting aside the humanitarian issues of "if you aren't going to behave the way we want you to, you get thrown out of society and are left to presumably starve and die" the simple fact is that walling them off is going to be exceptionally difficult to do, just for the logistics and the construction required. Not to mention, even if you make the laws pretty permissive, I have a feeling you'd have a lot more have-nots than haves, and at the end of the day, numbers do matter...
I agree numbers matter, which is why I asked if you had a ballpark on them. I guess you don't?
This study shows that just giving people a home is not only vastly superior ethically, but helps these people get OUT of that situation and in many ways can be cheaper too.
I'm asking whether paying the dane geld is really the most cost effective solution to this problem. I think we've now agreed that it's not actually a real problem, and probably just a post-hoc justification for what you really want to do?
It seems to me that the problem isn't that you can't put a monetary value on these activities. The problem is that these activities have high positive externalities. Most of the benefits due to these activities accrue to society at large, and not the individual engaging in the activity. As a result, individuals will tend to undervalue the activity compared to its total societal value.
Everyones problems, your problems, my problems. I spend every week interacting with people that I give money to that solve small but important problems for me.
In fact I have to call my bank soon to help me solve a problem with initiating a wire transfer, and i have no doubt the person on the other end of the line hates working in a call center, but I still need his help solving a problem.
Can you have an economic discussion without measuring things in dollars? Aren't value measurements intrinsic to economics?
This deliberate exclusion is already happening. I'm suggesting we should acknowledge the deliberate exclusion, or start including it, even if it makes the arguments more complex.
That is, of course, bullshit. But it doesn't stop them.
Beyond food, shelter, health care, communication, transportation... what are our needs, exactly? What problem do we solve by having most adults devoting the majority of their waking hours to something they actively dislike?