News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For loops help - comp.lang.c by Silhouette on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @10:42AM (#1341040)
> Regardless of whether or not the original post was rude is no excuse for a rude answer.

The answer wasn't rude, it was just unhelpful.

For those not familiar with the culture on comp.lang.c and the various related C and C++ groups, it is very simple: people will generally be helpful in dealing with homework questions as long as the asker has made a genuine effort.

On the other hand, anyone who just reposts homework verbatim with no effort whatsoever to solve the problem first is likely to find themselves given a very clever answer that is technically correct but clearly completely implausible for a beginner, thus making it very obvious to the teacher that the person is cheating on their homework. I recall a similar example where someone asked how to work out factorials in C++, and was presented with a highly efficient answer... because it used template metaprogramming and generated that answer at compile time.

This was certainly clear in the related FAQs last time I checked, so anyone who asks a homework question without making any effort to solve it themselves is not only lazy but also incapable of following basic netiquette. I doubt you'd find many regular posters on those groups who had much sympathy, even though some of those same posters give up a great deal of time to help those who are making a genuine effort to improve.

Re:For loops help - comp.lang.c by foldr on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @03:37PM (#1342009)
>The answer wasn't rude, it was just unhelpful.

Being deliberately unhelpful is rude.

Re:For loops help - comp.lang.c by moron4hire on Thursday May 13, 2010 @12:00AM (#1343242)
So is your time valuable or not? Is your time is too valuable to waste on people who don't put in a genuine effort, or is it not valuable enough that posting an unhelpful answer isn't a waste of effort? That's my point, it's easier for you to just ignore the bad poster. And yes, a deliberately unhelpful answer is rude.