News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by dogma1138 on Sunday January 15, 2017 @07:16PM (#13407381)
The problem is that you assume they will assimilate, based on the current 2nd and 3rd generation MENA immigrants in Europe that might not be the case.

Europe isn't a good place for assimilation, you can be a 3rd generation "immigrant" living in France but you will not be French regardless of how PC they might appear to be.

European nationality is very much based on blood ties to the land, ethnic nationality was the driving force behind the emergence of Nations in Europe in the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries.

Trying to compare them to "new world" nations, and specifically the US isn't really appropriate. The US was built by immigrants and the moment you arrive regardless of who you are or where you come from (to some degree) you are an American, this is not the same for many European nations.

Additionally it seems that judging by past MENA immigration patterns assimilation is also very much opposed by the communities at large, even communities that socio-economically are not ghettos like many immigrant neighborhoods and even whole towns still seem to rather change their environment to fit their culture rather than assimilate to the existing one.

Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by mattm on Sunday January 15, 2017 @11:30PM (#13408205)
> the moment you arrive regardless of who you are or where you come from (to some degree) you are an American

Unless you were Irish, Italian, Jewish, African, Middle Eastern, Muslim, Japanese, Mexican...

Don't pretend that the US is somehow morally superior in the way they have treated immigrants in the past and tidy.

Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by dogma1138 on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:11AM (#13409741)
Don't confuse individual racism with national identity. To be a French or Dutch is very different than being an American.

No one is pretending that the US is some paradise without prejudice but once you take the oath of allegiance you are an American regardless of your background.

Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by ralfn on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:41AM (#13409884)
As a dutch person ive heard this complaint as well. Although we dont really understand how it comes they dont feel like Dutch, the remark is common enough that there has to be something there.

I do want to add that strong social security doesnt seem to help with integration. I think part of the success of the US together with generational patience, is that to make a living you have to play along. So any economic mismatch is corrected by "force". Whereas here you can get a situation where the cultural values and habits that do not econonically fit (like raising your daughters to be housewives) are essentially supported by the welfare state, creating the opposite effect of how it is intended.

Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by dogma1138 on Monday January 16, 2017 @07:16PM (#13414213)
It should not be taken as a complaint, it's just what it is.

New world nations were founded on the premise of immigration and building a better world for yourself, people joke about the American dream but to some extent that is true.

Being an American or even a Canadian is more about the future and what you make out of yourself.

Being Dutch, German, French or Italian or many other nations is more about the past, you are who you are based on where you come from.

I'm not sure that this can change, nor do I necessarily think it should change, every nation and every nationality has it's own unique definition many of those are based on shared heritage and history which is tied to ethnic and familial roots. It's "easy" to become a Dutch citizen but it's nearly impossible to become a Dutch national, in the US there is very little distinction since virtually everyone there is a migrant at some point or another, and while if we go back to the stone age you may also call European migrants for the US it's much more recent history. The majority of the US population is 5 or less generations "American", compare it to the average Dutch or French native family and you get quite a different story.

Re:Is Europe Disintegrating? by vilmosi on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @05:54AM (#13416474)
>>> Don't confuse individual racism with national identity

I don't believe he's talking about individual racism but systematic racism employed by the US government, which historically preferred people from a certain background.

Italians and Irish people weren't even considered white. Chinatowns were basically invented in the US because Asian immigrants wouldn't (or not allowed to) integrate.