This is a good comment. The left saw much success after the New Deal because of its pro-labor stance...as society evolved, it came to encompass a whole bunch of rather polarizing issues rather than simply being "labor v/s corporation" and that seems to have reduced their appeal to the rural populace.
Re:Silicon Valley Takes a Right Turn
by eli_gottlieb on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:59PM
(#13402426)
Except that by now, labor has been weakened and economic inequality has increased to the point that the Old Left is clamping its hand over the New Left's mouth and taking over the title of "left-wing" again.
Universal basic income is one of the few ideas that the Old-Left and New-Right can agree on, but it's the internationalist New-Left that gets stymied by it.
- it implies very strong immigration controls, as a no-questions-asked massive cheque is one heck of an attractor for immigration. (And you're not going to get every country in the world to introduce it simultaneously.)
- in the same vein as Charter Schools, it implies the state having less say over your individual choices than if the state were providing services directly (and the state instead of the consumer deciding what shape they should be).
The New Left, which to be brutal fell into the trap of caring mostly that everyone should be expected to agree with it (be pro-immigration, secularist, etc) or otherwise they must be horrible / deplorable people, gets painted out on both counts. Stronger immigration controls make international city-hopping harder, and weaker control over services (if the state is just handing out cash) makes it harder to press everyone to fall in line and hold the same opinions.
One of the up-sides of "the return of protectionism" might actually be that you need those conditions to allow a UBI to be introduced.