Re:The Road from Serfdom - an interview with F.A. Hayek
by tokenadult on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:28PM
(#1339606)
Nobody thinks it would be efficient to privatize the federal highway system and turn everything into a toll road.
The key word there is "everything." It is efficient to turn some parts of the Interstate Highway system into toll roads, and if you have driven in certain states you have seen that done.
"The Indiana Toll Road is part of the U.S. Interstate Highway System which runs 157 miles through Indiana connecting the Chicago Skyway to the Ohio Turnpike."
"Historically, the Chicago Skyway was signed as, and was widely considered to be part of, I-90 from the mid-1960s forward. However, around 1999, the city of Chicago realized they had never received official approval to designate the Skyway as I-90. The city subsequently replaced most of the 'I-90' signage with 'TO I-90' signage. However, the Illinois DOT has always and continues to report the Skyway as part of the Interstate system, and the Federal Highway Administration apparently still considers the Chicago Skyway an official part of I-90.[7]
"The Skyway's official name, referring to it as a 'toll bridge' rather than a 'toll road,' is the result of a legal quirk. At the time of its construction, the city charter of Chicago did not provide the authority to construct a toll road. However, the city could build toll bridges, and it was found that there was no limit to the length of the approaches to the bridge. Therefore, the Skyway is technically a toll bridge with a six-mile-long approach. This also is part of the reason that there are no exits available until after one has crossed the bridge and paid the toll."
Where it is most economically efficient to operate a road as a toll road rather than as a road supported by general taxation depends much on local geographical factors. Note that Adam Smith has a very thoughtful discussion of the economics of road tolls (he considered them a remarkably fair form of taxation) in his 1776 book The Wealth of Nations. Many of his economic arguments apply well to taxation of gasoline to fund road projects.
The key word there is "everything." It is efficient to turn some parts of the Interstate Highway system into toll roads, and if you have driven in certain states you have seen that done.
"The Indiana Toll Road is part of the U.S. Interstate Highway System which runs 157 miles through Indiana connecting the Chicago Skyway to the Ohio Turnpike."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Toll_Road
"Historically, the Chicago Skyway was signed as, and was widely considered to be part of, I-90 from the mid-1960s forward. However, around 1999, the city of Chicago realized they had never received official approval to designate the Skyway as I-90. The city subsequently replaced most of the 'I-90' signage with 'TO I-90' signage. However, the Illinois DOT has always and continues to report the Skyway as part of the Interstate system, and the Federal Highway Administration apparently still considers the Chicago Skyway an official part of I-90.[7]
"The Skyway's official name, referring to it as a 'toll bridge' rather than a 'toll road,' is the result of a legal quirk. At the time of its construction, the city charter of Chicago did not provide the authority to construct a toll road. However, the city could build toll bridges, and it was found that there was no limit to the length of the approaches to the bridge. Therefore, the Skyway is technically a toll bridge with a six-mile-long approach. This also is part of the reason that there are no exits available until after one has crossed the bridge and paid the toll."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Skyway
Where it is most economically efficient to operate a road as a toll road rather than as a road supported by general taxation depends much on local geographical factors. Note that Adam Smith has a very thoughtful discussion of the economics of road tolls (he considered them a remarkably fair form of taxation) in his 1776 book The Wealth of Nations. Many of his economic arguments apply well to taxation of gasoline to fund road projects.