b) Google has become really smart nowadays. You could theoretically game everything in this world. They execute the javascript and run the page, they already know how to detect banners, interstatials etc. They also have manual team giving out bans.
Citation?
The six years is the age of the speed PageRank signal, according to the grandparent post.
"Hasn't improved things," I had assumed 'the web is getting slower' was common knowledge, but here's an example of the family of articles you can quickly find on the subject: http://www.webperformancetoday.com/2015/07/08/news-sites-tak...
Here's a fast loading, well designed webpage: http://myfreeweather.com/
yet when I search for "weather", all of the results are slow, terribly designed sites. The above site is nowhere to be found. The same goes for other "common" sites like lyrics, etc.
Yes, the problem that AMP is trying to solve is real, they are just going about it in the opposite way that they should be.
https://moz.com/blog/how-website-speed-actually-impacts-sear...