Re:Confirm or Deny: Peter Thiel
by krapp on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:29PM
(#13379148)
> Preferring a future of the same old debtors and creditors as today, to one where plentiful energy can be transformed into any kind of matter the human race needs, eliminating the need for money?
I'm not necessarily a Thiel fan, but to be fair, preference is irrelevant when only the former of those choices is actually possible in our universe. And he's right, at least as far as Gene Roddenberry was concerned, the utopian future was a Communist one, albeit one where the laws of physics were apparently sent to the camps during the Eugenics Wars.
Although, also to be fair, Star Wars has space wizards instead of technobabble, and the more deeply it delved into its economic and political systems in the prequels, the more ridiculous it seemed. Neither franchise would seem able to serve as a credible platform for the exploration of any complex political or economic idea.
But the original Star Trek was pretty capitalist as well, what with Harry Mudd running around the galaxy selling off-brand pharmacueticals and alien technology, the Federation exploiting dilithium miners, the Orion Syndicate, etc.
And, of course, after TNG, we get the Ferengi, who are obvious parodies of American capitalism, but not the villains.
I'm not necessarily a Thiel fan, but to be fair, preference is irrelevant when only the former of those choices is actually possible in our universe. And he's right, at least as far as Gene Roddenberry was concerned, the utopian future was a Communist one, albeit one where the laws of physics were apparently sent to the camps during the Eugenics Wars.
Although, also to be fair, Star Wars has space wizards instead of technobabble, and the more deeply it delved into its economic and political systems in the prequels, the more ridiculous it seemed. Neither franchise would seem able to serve as a credible platform for the exploration of any complex political or economic idea.
But the original Star Trek was pretty capitalist as well, what with Harry Mudd running around the galaxy selling off-brand pharmacueticals and alien technology, the Federation exploiting dilithium miners, the Orion Syndicate, etc.
And, of course, after TNG, we get the Ferengi, who are obvious parodies of American capitalism, but not the villains.