What are they going to charge him with? Violation of the gag order by saying and doing nothing? That would only serve to ridicule the whole practice.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrant_canary
In September 2014,[18] US security researcher Moxie Marlinspike wrote that "every lawyer I've spoken to has indicated that having a 'canary' you remove or choose not to update would likely have the same legal consequences as simply posting something that explicitly says you've received something.
Lawyers clearly disagree with you.
Gag orders seem to do exactly what they're supposed to: They scare people into compliance. Are there actually any cases where someone was charged for breaking a gag order?
Of course they do. Jail-time & heavy fines are typical for court imposed gag orders. I don't know of any examples of NSL gag orders being broken, nor do I expect you'll find any volunteers that want to find out.
Report the gag order stolen. Make a photo with a one-time camera and post it from an open wifi using Tails or another Linux live distribution. Shred the data, burn the order, dispose the camera.
This can even be scripted easily to happen automatically when you're in range of the wifi, so you're not seen with the device.
There are a lot of ways to safely disclose gag orders if you really want to, especially if you work in IT.
I don't think they ever want things like that to go to court, because proving that somebody gave away information implicitly can be very much impossible.
The "scare" part is all there is to gag orders, as far as implicitly disclosing information is concerned.
What are they going to charge him with? Violation of the gag order by saying and doing nothing? That would only serve to ridicule the whole practice.
Gag orders seem to do exactly what they're supposed to: They scare people into compliance. Are there actually any cases where someone was charged for breaking a gag order?