Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by nicky0 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:42PM
(#13366892)
This is probably the worst advice about depression I have ever read. "Spend time thinking about how to fix your problems" is about the last thing someone with depression needs to be told.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Sorry. I tried to be careful to say 'see if it's this' - I think people who have spent time depressed either completely agree with what I've said, or completely disagree. Probably there's two distinct things we're calling depression.
Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by angry-hacker on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @01:53PM
(#13367725)
Someone with psychiatric history bigger than bible I say it's not a bad advice. People are nowadays oversensitive, you don't need ta apologize front and backwards for anyone who might feel offended.
But your advice works if people have support network, it's tough alone.
And when you realize doctors diagnose everyone out of their ass, you get more depressed. After 10 minutes she claims you lack serotonin. On what bases? I even don't know what to say, life is bullshit but stop with being so sensitive, even if you're wrong, dsm and all your doctors use as much as real science than your average hn commenter.
> Probably there's two distinct things we're calling depression.
If you haven't been formally diagnosed, please for the love of god stop talking about "depression". You have no idea what it actually is.
On the one hand, there's the formal monopoly on the term that you cite. On the other, one is constantly reminded that "millions of Americans..." have undiagnosed cases of this thing. If not depression, what do I call this condition that grounded me for a decade, and did the same to many people I've known for comparable periods? Getting out of the house to get a formal diagnose wasn't even possible. It may be that I have no idea what it actually is. In that case I'd like to communicate with whoever is in a state like the one I was in, but I don't know what to call them. "Being depressed?"
Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by notyourloops on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @03:49PM
(#13368841)
It takes less than 15min to be formally diagnosed with depression and prescribed SSRIs in the US.
If you're bored you can watch the commercials on TV to learn that it's a chemical imbalance, and then repeat that fact every time a discussion about depression surfaces.
Re:When You Are Depressed, Make Something
by cortesoft on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @06:56PM
(#13370490)
Even a formally diagnosed depression can be many different things. Depression (in the formal and clinical sense) can have myriad causes, symptoms, and cures. Everyone who reads about any of these causes, symptoms, and cures needs to be aware that it may not apply to their specific depression. That doesn't mean we should stop talking about the various causes, symptoms, and cures that are out there, just because we fear giving someone with depression the wrong information.