News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cultural differences may leave their mark on DNA by tristor on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:31PM (#13366752)
I am not a geneticist, so perhaps I misunderstand, but the conclusion I formed seems to be reinforced by the quotes from the authors in the article. That is, there are specific gene expressions which are relevant in a medical context affected by cultural factors that are genetically transmitted. Genetic transmission at least to me implies that a person receives these things from their parents at birth, regardless of their own specific upbringing, because of cultural factors of their parents upbringing, and so on. As in, cultural differences can be expressed over time as genetic differences.

“These data suggest that the interplay between race and ethnicity as social constructs and genetic ancestry as a biological construct is more complex than we had realized,” said Noah Zaitlen, PhD, a UCSF assistant professor of medicine and co-senior author on the new study. “In a medical context both elements may provide valuable information.”

Setting aside the fact that this is such a touchy issue that the authors are carefully couching their language, it looks like there may be ways in which this new information can help people by tailoring medical treatments. I'd love a ELI5 explanation of this if I'm somehow misunderstanding, but the conclusion I formed seems to be supported by the article to my reading of it.

Note, I'm not taking a hardline stance. That's why I said "race is not just a social construct" in my conclusion.

Re:Cultural differences may leave their mark on DNA by openasocket on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:49PM (#13366983)
Gene expression is partially inherited and partially a product of environment. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_epigenetic_i...

The classic example discussed is a study of children born during a famine. Children born during famine are going to be smaller than normal, but it was found that their children and grandchildren would be born smaller than normal, even though the famine has long since passed. This change has been attributed to a particular methylation pattern that was passed down.

It's known that things like exposure to famine and abuse can change methylation patterns, but this study suggests that non-traumatic things like your cultural upbringing can affect methylation.

Re:Cultural differences may leave their mark on DNA by tristor on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @02:54PM (#13368329)
Thanks for the link. I read that, it seems to support my conclusion of this article as well. "As in, cultural differences can be expressed over time as genetic differences."

It seems like the debate we're having is a rehash of nature vs nurture, where it seems like the new research indicates nurture can affect nature for future generations through gene expression.