News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:07PM (#13366458)
Where do you draw the line? Should people be able to sell their kidneys? How about retinas? How about both kidneys? It's their body, after all.
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by virmundi on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:26PM (#13366697)
Yes. To all of that. The second kidney would be a death sentence. If they sell it, they can do it for whatever reason they want. It is theirs. Life is not something to be held on to at all costs. Perhaps selling two kidneys would end that person's suffering and the resulting funds would end their children's or their friends'.

People make calculated risks all of the time. My parents are not cool with me starting my own company that sells software services. They think that is a terrible risk. It is. I could lose everything. But I'm free to do that under the law.

People take calculated risks when logging. Dismemberment is a real threat. Yet the funds they could make are worth it to them. Who are you to tell them they can't?

I mean it when I ask, "Who are you to tell the they can't?" On what moral or ethical grounds do you restrict a person's liberty? If the worst that can happen is they die, why does that give you the authority to intervene against their wishes?

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:29PM (#13366728)
People take calculated risks when logging, but the logging industry has intensive safety requirements. There's a difference between accepting a heavily mitigated risk and exchanging money for your certain demise. This is a slippery slope argument; in a technical but real sense we accept mortal risk whenever we leave the house.

Do you think parents should be allowed to sell both kidneys in exchange for, say, fully-funded college tuition for their kids?

Do you think the mentally ill should be able to sell both their kidneys? Why or why not?

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by virmundi on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:54PM (#13367025)
> Do you think parents should be allowed to sell both kidneys in exchange for, say, fully-funded college tuition for their kids?

Ideally no more than one parent, presuming a two parent household, but yes, I'm morally okay with that. The loss of a parent is sad. It will have an emotional impact. I think that the impact, coupled to the education the parent is seeking will probably cause the child to appreciate and succeed even more. Knowing that dad died to procure the college education will probably cause the child to work harder in HS and college.

The parents have agency. They can look at a situation to see if they can get an outcome they appreciate.

> Do you think the mentally ill should be able to sell both their kidneys? Why or why not?

No, but merely on the arbitrary like that I think agency matters. Agency underlying all things is a premise. I just state it as a fact. If that fact is wrong, all conclusions from it are at risk. I accept that philosophically. I also posit that mental illness precludes agency.

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:09PM (#13366476)
I don't know if I agree with their arguments, but people have argued that people should be able to sell kidneys.

Currently, this is illegal - people end up forming "donation chains" to spread the availability of organs.

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by clavalle on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:23PM (#13366665)
I think people should be able to sell their organs, too /if/ they are perfectly free to make that choice and in no way coerced, actively or passively, to do so.

But, in a world where one can sell their organs, would we refuse public assistance to people who still have both of their kidneys? Would we say to the poor "Why are you asking for help? You have $50,000 buried in your back! Come back when you are truly desperate."

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:15PM (#13366566)
Of course, there are coherent arguments for this. Among other things, it makes organs more available to recipients. But then where do you draw the line from there? If the principle is "my body my rules", why not sell both kidneys?
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by joering2 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:22PM (#13366649)
Why not? You stupid to sell both kidneys you die. How is that your problem?? If I have a need to help other people to the extend that it will kill me, let it be!
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:25PM (#13366690)
Then, should people be allowed to accept money to "perform" in snuff films? Or is it only OK to sell ones life if there's some material net benefit to other people that results from it?
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by existencebox on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:12PM (#13366523)
Let me pose a question to you. (Or perhaps a rephrasing of your own) Should we allow people to end their own lives?

And at the point that we do, would we disallow them from also selling their organs?

I'll openly admit I err on the side of allowing one full control over their body; as someone staring down the barrel of dementia/Alzheimer, I selfishly want that choice when the time comes.

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:14PM (#13366554)
Are you asking because you want to know what I personally think? Remember, I'm just trying to get a coherent principle out of an angry objection.

I think we should allow assisted suicide but regulate it carefully. I do not think we should sell the organs of people who end their lives this way (not that there's likely to be a market for those organs).

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by existencebox on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @02:09PM (#13367888)
Was primarily curious to what the argument would be from someone taking the other side of this debate; if you think your personal opinion would build on that I'd naturally also be curious.

Regarding your second point on selling organs, for me it would heavily depend on our medical understanding of the transmission of whatever the critical condition was. If there is good science that e.g. Alzheimer patients can still be kidney donors, I'd think it'd be both impractical and unjust not to release those organs as the owner sees fit.

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by savanaly on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:09PM (#13366480)
Having consensual sex with someone isn't the same as giving up both your kidneys and retinas.
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by blhack on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:11PM (#13366519)
Coerced consent isn't consent.
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:15PM (#13366570)
That's true but irrelevant given the argument I'm responding to.
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by joering2 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:21PM (#13366635)
I don't "draw a line" with someone elses body. Why would you? This is why the government can get so deep in our lives because people want to "Care" for other people's own bodies.

If someone needs money to pay for their mother's surgery (on out of billion possible examples), then yes let them sell their kidney!

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by tptacek on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:48PM (#13366970)
What about both kidneys?
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by joering2 on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @02:50PM (#13368291)
What about them?
Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by saint_fiasco on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:42PM (#13366890)
Kidneys and retinas are actually an easier case, compared to prostitution. Transplants are difficult surgeries that require hospitals and specialized labor, so they are very easy to regulate.

Of course people should be able to sell their organs if they have permission of a doctor (who would get in trouble if they authorize a coercive transplant, just like euthanasia) and the recipient (who should be decided ahead of time to discourage organ hoarders and ensure compatibility)

Re:Backpage Shuts Down Adult Ads in the U.S., Citing Governm... by fixermark on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @12:09PM (#13366487)
Generally, we draw it somewhere south of "Permanent physical damage to one's own body" and somewhere north of "I could sit in my underwear and watch anime all day, but if I put on these pants and go sit in this cube and write this code for these people, I'll make some money, so..."