Thing is though it's an OS tied to a certain hardware since years. If Apple couldn't provide a seamless experience it'd be pure incompetence.
Good for you. I've never owned a MBP, and this thread is about switching from Debian to FreeBSD.
You completely missed the point. If ACPI is a mess, how come macOS doesn't suffer from the issue?
Look, I'm sure the macOS implementation of ACPI is great.
I said "I GUESS ACPI is a mess", because most implementations I've used (and I've only used it; I know nothing low-level about it at all) have had some problem or another.
How wrong of me not to have any experience with your preferred platform, and leave it out of the discussion.
That is why I told the reader (anecdotal) evidence which suggests the contrary.
> How wrong of me not to have any experience with your preferred platform, and leave it out of the discussion.
No need to feel so overly offended.
Of course, you don't mention macOS. I never had issues with suspend on any of my MBPs. If I did, it turned out that was my battery got empty, and the few times this happened I did think about suspend failing. Turned out I was wrong.