But your second point seems pretty reasonable; I'm still not sold. Can you go into more detail as to how the presence of glowing soot in one kind of fire - and absence in the other - would create the appearance of solidity (or lack thereof)?
Edit: Sorry, that came out real aggressive. I mean, can you throw some more words at how the glowing soot changes the look of the fire - regardless of the artistic interpretation of the difference?
There are absolutely differences between various flames burning in various conditions. When it comes to burning hydrocarbons (propane, methane, kerosene, gasoline, etc), that difference has more to do with the fuel/air mixture than it has to do with the specifics fuel. It is a lot easier to get a good fuel/air mixture when burning a gas like Propane. When a pool of liquid is burning, it is almost impossible to get a good mixture of fuel and air (even with a bunch of fans), so it is burning fuel rich, resulting in a lot of unburned fuel intermixed with the flame.
I would suggest Periodic Videos recent video about the bunsen burner. They achieve both sorts of flames you're talking about with a single fuel source (methane).
To get back on topic: "Glowing soot" or Blackbody radiation emitted by solid particles in a flame, is by pyrotechnic standards, a washed out flame. Smoke as a background is best not burning. Pretty simple math - to get a red flame of 50 lumens to appear as red when background has gone up to 100 lumens requires a 150 lumen flame. This is why we don't use fireworks in the daylight.
Source: Chapter 11 and 21 in fireworks practices and principals https://exploders.info/Files/Library/eng/pyrotechnics/firevo...
Well, yeah, that would make a way more effective argument, but I'd have to obtain a a) manual camera, b) sizable propane fire c) sizable kerosene/etc fire, d) b & c having nearly identical brightness, and e) a place and time to do it. These are doable, but not on an internet-debate timeline.
Think about the differences in your experience with propane and wood fired fireplaces. Most people have had at least one experience with both, and those are the only things I can think of where the flames in both are of comparable size/brightness.
> Smoke as a background is best not burning I'm sorry, I don't understand. Are you missing a word, maybe?
> [link] Amazeballs link, thank you! Do you know the name of the fireworks that produce large quantities of specifically fire? I know them as "gas bombs", but I have no idea if that's the correct technical term.
Our eyes and brains are very, very good at working at vastly different lighting conditions and presenting the results similarly. That's why they noted that one should use a camera to compare because our eyes are lying to us. (Seriously: Try to guess proper exposure needed for a photo just with your eyes. Even with experience it's hard and you're likely to be off by one or two EV (i.e. a factor or two or four in brightness!)).
However, if you have EXIF info you can probably still compare brightness of flames across photos, as an image's brightness only depends on the actual scene brightness, ISO, aperture and exposure time. And the latter three are merely factors.