News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moral panic over fake news hides the real enemy – the dig... by pessimizer on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:14PM (#13352377)
It's bizarre that you try to force things into a conservative/"liberal" linear continuum. These are not real categories, these are media categories, "liberal" as Americans use it is simply a made-up word, and many right-wing traditionalist nationalists all over the world tend towards socialism.

This is about power, and how sovereignty has moved from the sovereign to the populace, but now to the powerful. The sovereign was expected to be ruling on behalf of the deity (or as the deity) and had a responsibility to tend and care for its creation. With popular sovereignty, representatives of the people were supposed to focus the people's will in order to accomplish the people's goals. Under neoliberal capitalism, the wielders of power are specifically admonished to only be concerned about their own interests, so as not to break the forces that automagically put everything to right. To the extent that our governments are controlled by the wealthy, we live in a laissez-faire system, with laws as assets to be manipulated.

When the wielders of power have no moral obligation to anyone but themselves, they are untrusted, and untrustworthy. When the system recognizes no moral obligation, being caught in deception doesn't disqualify you from being rehired, it shows that you are willing to do what needs to be done to win.

People recognize this, and use what's left of their control of government to disrupt the current consensus as much as possible. Without Brexit or Trump, they would simply start murdering each other and the particular wielders of power who they feel hurt them the most.

Of course, I'm pretty much restating the article in a different way.

The reason people don't trust scientists is because they shouldn't.

-----

edit:

To make it personal, the reason I believe in global warming is because the profit motive tends to point in the other direction, and because my naive understanding of the mechanism sounds plausible. The fact that it remains the dominant theory when the dominant financing all goes in the other direction makes me attribute that dominance to a residual dedication to truth over self-interest in many scientists. It is not because scientific consensus is truth, which is a form of vulgar market-worship. It wouldn't surprise me at all if it turns out to be horseshit, and in retrospect should always have been seen as horseshit. It would surprise me if that happened, and there weren't also some other competing channel to self-interest that I wasn't aware of. I think that many suspect that the academic hierarchy represents that channel, and that's why they are suspicious of global warming.

There are no comments on this comment yet.