First, and most notably, they believe that being liberal means full embracement of leftist group think like the USSR had during its communist days. That is the most fundamental problem with reaching them since you can't unmoor the thought of leftism from liberalism with them.
They believe the scientific community has become strangled by this leftist/liberal ideology.
I'm not sure what happens next but I think it's bad for humanity. If half the population needs a reminder on why science is good I guess they'll get it. Usually that's mass death.
Identity politics is even worse than this. From what I can see, among people not totally ideologically driven, this discredits the left very much, and liberal values will be caught in the backlash.
I mean, yes, I would definitely say that that identity politics/bloc voting is problematic, from the perspective of "how do we best run a government?". It is also in many cases understandable, especially in the face of extant threats to a given polity. (In such a case, however, it is important to stress that "identity politics" is not the problem--the threat and disenfranchisement that led to the formation of an identity bloc is. Even for Trump voters, who I'll touch on momentarily.)
But from a social/messaging perspective, I think that it is less that identity politics discredits the left and more that white people (and it's mostly white people who have an axe to grind about identity politics) feel threatened by identity politics and thus by the left. The reactionary clumping of the Trumpist bloc of whites (as evidenced both by voting patterns and the frankly shameless xenophobic pandering by Trump and his surrogates in the campaign) is no less "identity politics", and is arguably more aggressive than the identity-focused blocs that have formed prior (it's a lot less aggressive to say "we should be able to get married" than it is to say "you should not be able to get married", get me?). But that's not castigated as "identity politics". I would submit that that's because white people don't think white is an identity, but the default.
Identity politics are fine, so goes the thinking, when it's your identity. In a society overwhelmingly dominated by white interests, fairness is gonna feel like you're losing. (This is the genesis of the notion of "privilege" in the first place, as I understand it.)
- The difference between discredited and threatening is academic, since both lead to the same mindset and course of action
- A large swing towards Trump was noticeable amongst minority voters, the poor, and whites without a degree[0], groups who would be expected to be harmed by competition from illegal immigration
- A large swing towards Hillary was observable in the rich, retirees, and whites with college degrees, groups which are generally believed to be well-to-do
- If fairness feels like losing, and losing feels like losing, then how can we tell which is which?
- If white people implicitly pursue identity politics even when they try not to, will making them aware of this lead to them laying aside identity, or actively pursuing it?
- If race-blindness/"I don't see colour" is a myth, is it a useful myth for the purposes of causing people to get along?
- Is it possible for any action taken against a group that is winning to be unfair? If yes, when might this occur? If no, are you really sure that winning justifies literally any action against you?
Note that I'm not American, so I'm looking at this with an outsider's perspective.
[0] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/08/us/politics/el...
There's a pretty big argument in the data communities that I follow about whether this was a "swing towards Clinton/Trump" or a (minor) normalization away from the Obama state. I don't think there's enough data to say either way. There are also a lot of rhetorical/conflating factors with regard to stuff like illegal immigration that make drawing conclusions out of this, in a vacuum, probably pretty questionable.
> If fairness feels like losing, and losing feels like losing, then how can we tell which is which?
Tough, but fair, question. I think it requires divorcing oneself from one's own position and trying, at least, to be objective about it. I was born with pretty much every genetic-lottery benefit there is in the United States: straight, white, male, reasonably affluent (though not rich) family. I am able to bite back the instinctive urge to be defensive about "what I've got" (and it is instinctive, and it does come up reflexively) to realize that, hey, not only do I have it pretty great, but a lot of it wasn't because of anything I did either way to make it happen. So maybe I should pay it forward.
If I can do it, I believe others should do likewise.
> If white people implicitly pursue identity politics even when they try not to
Mu? I think most people pursue identity politics. It's what outward pressures pushed you in what direction that ultimately defines what that identity is. I don't particularly worry about the concerns of white straight males, despite being one, because there are no serious threats to any of those qualities that I identify with.
I don't think making identity politics a topic of discussion will swing people who are strongly affected by the pull of it in either direction. I don't think people who are voting along identity lines care about whether or not they are.
> If race-blindness/"I don't see colour" is a myth, is it a useful myth for the purposes of causing people to get along?
This is a good question. My intuitive answer is no, if only because it provides a good excuse through which systemic, race-focused effects can be marginalized. "I don't see race, so it's not a problem that cops disproportionately shoot black people." Not saying this is a logical chain of reasoning in quotes, but rather that I've seen it, and "I don't see race" being used to buttress the moral credentials of the claim.
> Is it possible for any action taken against a group that is winning to be unfair? If yes, when might this occur?
Sure. I think lynching the 1% is a damned sight too far, and if that were a serious concern I'd definitely be on the yeah-let's-not-do-this side of the ledger. On the other hand, I don't think asking them to pay more for the benefits they reap from living in the country they share with everybody else, and disproportionately benefit from, is unfair.
I don't know if you looked at science lately, but the majority of the science published is actually not-that-great, if not bad. The public SHOULD distrust scientists - as well as most else.
But on the other hand, I think we can. The percentage of conservatives has declined rapidly in recent decades. We haven't seen an increase in scientific productivity because of that. Science worked just as well back when there were more conservatives doing it.
And we also see conservatives talking about how hard it is for them to be themselves on campuses. It isn't that their politics interfere with them doing science. It is that they are a hated minority.
The conservative movement that attacks facts because facts refuse to coexist with their ideology was a Pat Buchanan minority before about 1990 and didn't exist in the mainstream of political thought before about 1970. Do you realize that the modern conservative movement defined "reality-based community" as a pejorative because they believed they could simply create their own realities[1]?
Turns out that when you fight reality, reality fights back. It's not really a surprise that burning effort on that struggle is not conducive to scientific pursuits.
> And we also see conservatives talking about how hard it is for them to be themselves on campuses. It isn't that their politics interfere with them doing science. It is that they are a hated minority.
When your belief system is predicated upon what modern conservatism is predicated upon, yes, you're going to be disliked. It is a very dislikable system of belief! And I mean, I'm speaking from experience. It wasn't that long ago when I was one of those Campus Conservatives, speaking truth to the Liberal Elites. I delighted in being the gadfly. I got shit because I acted like a little shit. (And I regret it now, because my desire to be Loudly and Emphatically Conservative actually hurt people; I was never so broken as to fall in with the racists and the homophobes, but I had no problem with the very morally upright hang-the-poors ideology and saw nothing wrong with "well, why don't they just work harder?".) So pardon me for being real skeptical about how very oppressed they are.
[1] - http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/17/magazine/faith-certainty-a... (the puncher quote there is largely believed to be from Karl Rove)
But to the main thrust of your post, I've seen those characterizations of the left, too. I made those characterizations of the left. I was wrong then, and I was wrong precisely because I was evaluating the left positions based on postulates that were horseshit. Not that I would ever make criticisms based on those postulates, 'cause I knew those were loser arguments. It was not until I was able to broaden my horizons and learn a certain structural courage to challenge them that I realized that they were not just loser arguments because those principles were not well-shared but loser arguments because those principles were gross.
Even Reagan (who I view as kind of the beginning of this ideological rot in conservatism) was able to talk about fundamental principles of his conservatism. Whatever Trump's fundamental principles are, he speaks not to them. Nor does a Paul Ryan, for a more establishment conservative. My conclusion is that either those principles don't exist or they are repugnant enough that someone with savvy knows to run from them.
YM, of course, MV. You don't have to agree with me. But I believe, and believe strongly, that someone who does not have or does not speak to their principles, towards the points that orient their moral compass, knows that they are wrong.
There is no symmetry. 37% identify as conservatives, 35% as moderates, and 24% as liberals[1]. That leaves 4% for "other". So we're actually talking about 63% of the country being "non-crazy" or "non-propagandized", although I suspect that many self-identified conservatives despise what the Republican Party has become.
[1] -- http://www.gallup.com/poll/188129/conservatives-hang-ideolog...
On the other hand, I am mostly sympathetic towards conservative people. Most have been sold a bill of goods and were never fortunate enough to stumble across, or have delivered unto them, the structural education necessary to evaluate it one way or another. (This includes functionally-trade-schooled "engineers". The best thing that ever happened to me in my fundamental learning was having to take economics, philosophy, and sociology classes. The idea that a "Bachelor's of Science" can be granted with only minimal exposure to the humanities is near-criminal.)
Where my sympathy fails is when the proponents of that ideology wish to use it to harm other people. That is the chilly response that conservatism gets in academia and it must not be ignored: when you are the self-appointed standard-bearer of a worldview where women, gays, and minorities are second-class citizens, when you are the representative of a worldview that wants fewer people to be able to vote so you can win, when "root, hog or die" is accompanied by no end of policies to ensure that Those People don't get that middle option and only sometimes get the first--of course people are going to react poorly to you. Don't actively shit on other people and they won't shit on you back.
I think the problem is that you need to define what conservatism is to you. Otherwise it's hard to really have a discussion about the label.
He's defined at least partially what it is to him ("conservative movement that attacks facts because facts refuse to coexist with their ideology") and frankly it's a group I can see many rational people being negative about.
But if conservatism to you is just slightly right of center on most things, I don't think people would be very negative about them and I definitely can't see them having any more trouble than usual on a college campus. Their views are going to be challenged there but that's kind of the point of college. And if being challenged is too high a mountain for them, a career in science isn't going to work out.
When you believe a minority viewpoint, you're going to be challenged more often than the mainstream--and you can refine your viewpoint under fire and make it better (the inability to make it better because there was no better to be made was a large part of what pushed me away from conservatism), or you can adopt a siege mentality and hide from it. I find that cowardice endemic to the modern right and its fragility the centerpiece of the hatred of even mild challenges.
I'm not a conservative, so I don't think I should be the one to define what it means? Instead, I listen to people that self-identify as conservative.
Without something resembling a common definition, you're going to have a hell of time having a sane, productive discussion.
Let that sink in for a moment and then reflect on what conservatism even means.
Because the Republican candidate deeply disagreed with most Republican ideas. For instance, he openly wants his government to "pick winners" in the marketplace and has repeatedly said he won't cut Social Security.
For the Party to fall in behind him on personality alone, while he speaks one heresy after another against their purported ideology, shows that they no longer have an ideology they preach in good-faith. They've become a bad-faith party, distinct from conservative parties in other countries, who just seek power, connections, and wealth for themselves, and say whatever's necessary to get it.
First, yes, Trump disagreed with a bunch of typical Republican ideas. But those turned out to be things that Republican voters wanted, even if the Republican party members didn't. Like his stance on trade.
Second, Trump loudly championed a lot of typical Republican causes, like the "Repeal and Replace Obamacare" mantra, being "pro-life", etc. Those seem like terrible ideas/policies to me and probably you, but Trump is a typical conservative on those.
So no, it wasn't on "personality alone."
He also disagreed loudly with those same positions at other times. He just doesn't consistently toe the conservative ideological line handed down by Republican Party leaders and intellectuals.
Now, that's definitely part of why his voter base like him, but it also means that he's still not an ideological conservative of the typical kind.
http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/19/politics/donald-trump-republic...
http://mitchellarchives.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/hitle...
If you were to then suggest that Republicans are not conservative--well, duh. ;)
What could possibly be wrong with this if he ran
and was endorsed on the GOP ticket?
Does the mere act of running on the GOP ticket absolve Trump of everything and anything? That appears to be the case for his supporters. Less so for the rest of us and when I refuse to accept Trump as normal, that is what I'm saying.Is there really data showing the proportion of scientists who are "conservative"? In what fields?
http://www.bostonmagazine.com/news/article/2016/12/20/libera...
This isn't new, it's been known for decades that academia leaned left, and in particular certain areas of it (humanities and social sciences).
Yes, but the question here is different: Has the proportion of conservatives diminished significantly? (tl;dr: Among 4-year colleges and universities in the U.S., according to one study, there has been a big change in New England but only a little elsewhere.)
And thanks for adding some actual facts to that discussion! Some thoughts on it, and a summary so that everyone doesn't have to read it:
The analysis is from Samuel Abrams, an apparently conservative[0] political science professor at Sarah Lawrence and the Hoover Institution. In looking up Abrams, I found an article that addresses his study plus other useful research and in a less biased way (the Boston Magazine article is titled "How Liberal Professors Are Ruining College" and mostly is anecdotes about persecution):
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/07/05/new-analysis-...
the Higher Education Research Institute at the University of California, Los Angeles, ... conducts periodic surveys of faculty members and asks them, among other things, about their political views. Recent surveys have shown that faculty members are moving more to the left than has been the case in the past.
Abrams analysis is of the above data, and shows that the ratios are holding mostly constant in most of the country but in New England the ratio of liberal-to-conservative has shot up from around 5:1 to 28:1:
http://cdn1.bostonmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/li...
He found that region was the most significant factor, even controlling for institution type of discipline of faculty members.
Also of interest: The HERI data are on four-year college and university faculty members, and much research suggests that community college faculty members are more centrist than are their four-year colleagues. Remember that very many people attend community colleges, regardless of their relative prominence.
Still open is how much of that change is due to the country moving right and the definition of conservative changing; for example, much of Ronald Reagan's politics would be anathema to current "conservative" leaders. But again, many thanks; the research definitely informs the conversation.
----
[0] Abrams is identified as centrist in one article and conservative in another. The Hoover Institution is conservative, AFAIK.
On the other hand, a Republican Congressman in Ohio who went on record as acknowledging that climate change is real and is happening would be primaried by his own party. There are things about which a Democrat would be primaried by his or her own party...but I think they'd be more like "attending a Klan rally" than "accepts that scientific consensus means things," and so we're talking differences in kind here, not merely degree.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/dec/16/new-fo...
Nuclear Power advocates on the left are frequently attacked by Greenpeace and many others.
As far as Acceptable Thought goes the practice of 'no platforming' and restricting free speech at Universities is not something that the Right originated. Again, that isn't debating with any assumption of good faith. That's just trying to block out views that the Left doesn't like.
The Family Research Council is a mainstream right-wing organization. A Republican who runs afoul of the FRC in a solidly Republican state is in danger of being challenged internal to the party. What The FRC Thinks matters a great deal to the discourse of the right.
Hell, I'll go one further: that I can criticize the insularity of parts of the left to hearing things they don't like is something that I could not do when I was of the right because then I was a RINO or a "bad Republican". I'm not a "bad liberal" because I make that criticism. I'm pretty normal. So there's a difference, and it's a difference of kind, and the conflation you're attempting to pawn off strikes me as mendacious.
So that's one theory, but it's difficult to really know because I (and probably most of the readers here) live in a blue city in a blue state, not a major city in the south where conservative ideas would be more likely to be intellectually fostered and furthered. Their strongest ideas tend to be related to economics and individual liberty, but they tend to just copy those ideas from libertarians and morph them in with other things that are not intellectually consistent (like being against regulation of non-localized forms of pollution). In general, both sides appear pretty consistently stubborn to accept anything that originated from the other side. Not HN intellectuals, but the layman (which makes up 95+% of both the Democrats' and the Republicans' voter base).
This is completely not true.
I think you might confusing 'popular' liberalism (i.e. progressivism) and 'popular' conservatism (i.e. evangelicals, social conservatism, small government etc.) - with actual liberalism and conservatism.
Universities were always fairly Conservative, it started to change in the 1940s-1960s.
The 'liberals' in University that people are complaining about are progressives - not liberals: 1) There is a lot of 'social justice ideology' that is not particularly scientific and more perversely 2) a lot of ideas are openly suppressed because they don't promote the ideological narrative of many academics.
The banishment of speakers, not allowing profs to talk about certain things because of potential 'trigger warnings', historical revisionism, and the shaping of courses to meet ideological narratives (CLASS Montreal protestors demanded a 'feminization' of the entire course material etc..) - none of this is remotely liberal by any definition.
In short: Universities liberal arts faculties are are illiberal institutions.
On the whole - I think it has much more to do with the admins and Uni culture - as defined by a vocal subgroup of students - than the course material itself.
The student unions are more than 50% of the problem.
Personally, I am fairly convinced that academia and science being "liberal" is, I think, much more a characteristic of the underlying philosophies involved than some externally-imposed groupthink. "Conservatism", at least the modern variant, and "exploring and expanding knowledge for a greater good, while entertaining ideas that you don't necessarily agree with" are literally antithetical. I thought of myself as a conservative before I went to college and realized that, hey, American conservatism is not only railing against stuff like observational science, but "morally" against the existence of these fellow human beings who have done nothing wrong and deserve to exist.
So, yeah, maybe "the public" would trust academia and the whole "science" thing more if it was More Conservative, but who's to say that it'd actually work as well? It's not like this stuff exists to tell people what they want to hear--and the epistemic closure of the American conservative is such an ideological purity test that if you're not telling them what they want to hear, you're not conservative. It's not on "science and academia" to break itself for such a warped thing, is it?