News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by davidedicillo on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:32PM (#1334946)
No news here.

1. More networks, more devices. It's like saying that Windows sells more than Macbook Pros. 2. Everyone and their mothers knows that in a month Apple will introduce a new one 3. Soon the big majority of cell phones will be what we usually call smartphones. It would be fool to think that one single device will maintain dominate the marketshare. The point is that if you look at the single device, no-one is even closed to Apple's number.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by detst on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:38PM (#1334973)
> The point is that if you look at the single device, no-one is even closed to Apple's number.

Really? Is that what matters? It seems to me the more significant thing would be the OS and not any one device, especially for HN-types that write apps and build sites for OSes/browsers and not a piece of hardware.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by javery on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:45PM (#1335009)
The most significant thing is actually what kind of market there is for the apps/sites we are building. Market is not just about the number of users, it's about how much those users are buying. It's the reason that Mac developers can make more than their PC counterparts on many types of applications, because the Mac users buy more software. (at least I know I have since I switched).
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by revaaron on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:26PM (#1335221)
My experience over the last few weeks spent using a new Nexus One as a former iPhone certainly supports this. Frankly, I'm stunned at the difference in quality and breadth of applications available in the App Store vs Android Market- compared to the App Store, the Market is like Softpedia or Tucows...
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by krschultz on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:58PM (#1335359)
The install base of the iPhone still dwarfs Android, this is unit sales for one quarter. The iPhone has been out for a while longer than Android.

But if this quarter a sign of things to come, what platform do you want to be selling apps on long term?

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by revaaron on Monday May 10, 2010 @05:09PM (#1335943)
I'd have to agree with slyn- both. I think it's most likely I'd be selling apps for Android in the long term, if only because I don't have to live by 3.3.1...

I wouldn't be surprised if a divide not unlike Mac vs PC software developed- traditionally, Mac users were a smaller group but more willing to pay for overall better software.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by lutorm on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @08:36AM (#1337593)
I just looked at the Android SDK for the first time the other day, and it seemed to indicate that you must write your apps in Java? That seems even more restrictive than 3.3.1 to me. Or did I miss something?
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by slyn on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:45PM (#1335535)
Both?
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by davidedicillo on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:50PM (#1335026)
The problem is that doing great applications that sells well it's harder when you need to make them looks polished like iphone ones with such a big variety of devices. Soon your fridge will use Android, that doesn't mean I'd like to develop apps for it.

Also iPhone users have been "trained" for years with iTunes to buy digital content.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by dannyr on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:26PM (#1335219)
When the IPhone was selling more than Android, Apple defenders were saying that you should choose a platform that has a bigger market (i.e. IPhone).

Now that Android is outselling the IPhone, you should now choose based how many users actually buy digital content.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by jasonwocky on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:58PM (#1335578)
I don't see a distinction between "bigger market" and "how many users actually buy digital content". I think these are the same thing.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by buster on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:41PM (#1334986)
"Soon the big majority of cell phones will be what we usually call smartphones." My guess here is, that this will be a major winning point for Android, as i think that the next-gen low cost smartphones (presumably the ones that will most likely be bought by current featurephone owners) will be Android ones. Vodafone in germany will sell an Android phone for 130€ (prepaid, 1€ with contract) soon, for example.

Even more so, this may be a huge advantage in the emerging markets like china and india.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by moultano on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:39PM (#1334977)
Does that matter to us? When I'm deciding what to support as a developer I care only about the size of the platform.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by dagw on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:23PM (#1335457)
If all you care about is number of potential users you should target either S60 or JavaME.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by grinich on Monday May 10, 2010 @05:29PM (#1336004)
Or HTML/JS.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by sueders100 on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:01PM (#1335120)
"Does that matter to us?" Yes, I imagine fragmentation would matter when it comes to developing for a platform.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by revaaron on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:29PM (#1335235)
Indeed. Fragmentation is probably the biggest reason we'll never see Android Market-sales on a per-device basis top what each iPhone user spends in the App Store- there's a wife range of CPU power, RAM, graphics capability, peripherals, multitouch or not, etc on Android devices. Like being back in the world of Windows CE...
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by not_an_alien on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:51PM (#1335323)
The same is happening to the iPhone ecosystem; at a slower pace, but it's happening. Before it was the iPhone 2G; now it's iPhone 2G, 3G, 3GS, iPad, soon the new iPhone 4G... soon there will be way too many differences in resolution, screen size, CPU and OS too.

Sales per-device is irrelevant, IMO. If I sell 100 for 10 devices, it's better than selling 90 for 3 devices. It's not like I have to add one IF() condition for each new model in my code; merely that I have to plan for slower CPUs and different screen sizes and resolutions, and when I do so, it's for a whole group of similar devices.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by catch23 on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:05PM (#1335391)
It's a bit different though -- if you look at stats on Flurry for some of the popular apps, you'll see that there is less than 3% iPhone OS 2.0 users out there. That's simply because iPhone users get a free OS upgrade when they hook up to iTunes. The majority of users who are still stuck in the 2.0 land are iPod Touch users since they actually have to pay for the 3.0 upgrade. That's why the iPhone market has significantly less fragmentation.

However, I have a HTC MyTouch android phone that is still stuck in 1.6 land. I upgraded from 1.5 recently, but it was not the simplest process to do so. HTC doesn't really make it easy for phone owners to upgrade their phone OS. It's possible for me to use the CyanogenMod to upgrade my OS to 2.0, but not without lots of effort at the command line.

The current slew of 1.5/1.6 android devices out there right now will probably never be upgraded to 2.x mostly because the phone manufacturers rarely make it an easy process.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by wan23 on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:13PM (#1335422)
People don't seem to notice that on the iPhone platform fragmentation is limited because people keep buying new devices.

Usage stats from my app in April (somewhat unscientific but illustrates my point decently): iPhone 3G: 49 users iPhone 3GS: 48 users iPod Touch 2nd Gen 4 users iPod Touch 1st Gen 3 users iPhone Edge 2 users iPod touch 1 user iPad 1 user (might have been me...)

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by MWinther on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:14PM (#1335426)
Well, the 2G is being phased out with the next OS release, meaning that even though people will still use their old one development will still be focused on a few core devices. The first major fragmentation will be with the new hi-res screen on the next iPhone, the 3G and 3GS aren't really that different to develop for.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by catch23 on Monday May 10, 2010 @01:59PM (#1335361)
I think you would care about making money more than the size of the platform. There was a time when MySpace had 2x more users than Facebook, but app developers on MySpace didn't have the same level of virility that Facebook apps had and thus it was far more lucrative to make FB apps.
Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by MWinther on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:08PM (#1335403)
I agree. Which is why those numbers aren't that interesting when comparing Android to iPhone OS, since iPod touches and iPads are a part of the platform.

That being said, it clearly says that the Android platform is growing.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by davidedicillo on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:59PM (#1335108)
It's not about the size of the market as much as the quality.

Would you rather have 100,000 potential users and make 1,000 sales or 200,000 users and make 800. Or maybe make the same amount of sale but being able to charge more because you know that who spend $500 for a phone is more incline to spend $10 on an app than somebody who spent $100?

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by krschultz on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:02PM (#1335377)
Ok, but that is a pile of assumptions.

If the iPhone user buys 3 apps for every 1 the Android user does, but in a couple years there are 10 times as many Android users, where do you sell your app?

The attach rate and the market size make all the difference, and there is no data to support the conclusion you are trying to make.

A gaming PC is a hell of a lot more expensive than a console, yet their attach rate is way way lower than a console.

Re:Android-based Smartphones Outpaced Apple's iPhone in Q1 2010 by ergo98 on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:36PM (#1335507)
>No news here.

Is this like "the seven stages of grief" or something?

Yeah, there is big news here, denial-be-damned.

A few short months ago we were all told that there was just so much confusion in Android-land. So many choices and so many versions it was a major turn off for consumers. Instead the one-sized-fits-all iPhone model was the winner (and it was). Now it's "duh...of course Android moves ahead" as if that's the new reality.

>Everyone and their mothers knows that in a month Apple will introduce a new one

The Nexus 2 will be out in a very short while. The Samsung Galaxy S will be out with 3x the GPU power. The Evo 4G of course. And on, and on, and on.

>The point is that if you look at the single device, no-one is even closed to Apple's number.

It was never about a single device. It has never been a single device.