Re:Wall Street jumps (S&P up nearly 6%) at open after global...
by CWuestefeld on Monday May 10, 2010 @12:59PM
(#1335105)
Upvoted - good criticism of my criticism. My reading was concentrating more on the "good or bad" part, rather than what area they're attributing the area to.
I think that's rather his point. It's well-understood here that movement in the market is but a tiny window into a huge range of financial bets.
But the overwhelming majority of financial reporting perpetuates the myth that the window is providing a value judgment on the economic impact a particular action.
E.g. We know an uptick following a bailout is as likely caused by a desire to cash in on a sucker's rally as by optimism about long-term value. But articles such as the above link persist in suggesting that the uptick means the bailout is good, or helpful, or assuages actual concerns.