As you say it is subjective. The main problem is:
- people plying their own agenda trying to prosecute people for moral or other ambiguous reasons
- inexpert officers doing an initial investigation/arrest; which leads to full investigations by experts into... ...nothing
The latter is always going to happen - and luckily we've got quite good at heading it off early (at least here anyway). The former is more of a problem - because if they are big enough (like this prosecutor it seems) to push it to court you can often get a jury onside by default :(
"It kind of boils down to a gut feeling. If it feels wrong, it probably is."
This is correct though; clearly his marker is a lot lower because my "gut" [based on a brief review] on that specific case is "probably ok". You do get a gut feeling about someone's intentions though (and the terrible thing is the number of times you just cannot, in honesty, prove it).
Society is chock full of prosecutors and citizens like the micro-brained David Cook who view almost anything 'natural' involving a youngster as 'sexual'.
http://reason.com/blog/2009/05/04/grandma-arrested-for-child...
The subjectivity of this topic lends itself to egregious abuse if minds have been soaked in morality acid.