I've heard this sentiment a lot. The reality is that UI libraries are inherently difficult to tree-shake. You can't run a library that can be used to produce an infinite range of outcomes and expect a tool like Rollup to whittle it down to just the bits you need (source: I'm the creator of Rollup).
Code is reused. While the compiler will output 'standalone' modules by default, it can also generate modules that share code between components — the zero-runtime part is about generating abstraction-free DOM manipulation code rather than having a complex virtual DOM reconciliation or data-binding process.
> rather than a new beautiful finished paradigm
Nowhere does it claim to be finished. If anything, it's the start of a new approach to building UIs.
Is that correct? If so, it's a very cool idea! (I'd been tossing this idea around for a few months last year, but had trouble designing a non-awful API xP)
I wish there were a way to make the messaging around this idea clearer. I know that audiences are different, and this wouldn't work for everyone. But if the introductory blog post had illustrated the transformation from component tree to data graph, I would've immediately understood the performance implications and how this represents a huge paradigm shift in application compilation.
Instead, though, I thought the pitch was "ew, separate runtime library? let's inline it and then it'll be smaller", which seemed misguided. I had to reverse-engineer Svelte's motivation from your comment—and even now I'm still not sure I got it right. (Maybe this entire comment is wrong? Could be wrong. No idea :/)
Are y'all planning a blog post about how Svelte works under the hood? That would go a long way toward clarifying the pitch, I think.
Both are solid ideas. (As the creator of Ractive I'm biased towards data-binding, but React's success speaks for itself.) But either way, the library has to do a lot of work to essentially just translate state changes into `element.setAttribute('foo', 'whatever')` and so on. Svelte was born out of a realisation that if you can understand the shape of your component graph at build time, you can eliminate those runtime abstractions — and with it, both the bytes and the computational cost associated with them.
> Are y'all planning a blog post about how Svelte works under the hood?
Yes, we have a lot of blog posts we need to write! Hopefully soon.
Direct DOM updates are slow (rerender), diffing and smart patching much faster. There must be a reason for virtual doms becoming so popular, even for frameworks that don't have a 'functional' approach like React.
Re-rendering your entire app (i.e. creating all the nodes from scratch with innerHTML or document.createElement) is too slow for a lot of apps, and is a bad idea for lots of other reasons (losing state in form elements, etc). Virtual DOM just gives you a way to write your app as though you were re-rendering it from scratch, while still being fast enough that you can get away with it.
Svelte is significantly faster than React according to https://github.com/krausest/js-framework-benchmark, because it's taking a more direct approach to the same goal — updating existing elements or only creating/destroying them as necessary. It's also faster than Ember, Angular, Vue, etc. It's not yet quite as fast as Inferno, but it uses less memory.
Inferno-1.1.0 have an error at runtime, could not test JS Framework right now. Sveltejs works.
I'd like to see some performance metrics from Svelte compared to page loads with other frameworks to see where the savings are.
The file size problem is about unused code, right? If we tree-shook the runtime and shipped the minimal version that our app needs, wouldn't that be even better for most apps than inlining the framework? I'd expect that, the moment you use a feature even twice, the runtime approach yields a smaller bundle.
Or is Svelte accepting a file size penalty to avoid the performance overhead of function calls? If so, it'd be nice to see that tradeoff discussed more explicitly: in every app, there are probably features worth inlining and features worth keeping as function calls.
Really, it sounds like Svelte is trying to solve a very general compilers problem with a very specific sledgehammer solution. Sure, tree-shaking and thoughtful inlining are difficult to do well, especially in Javascript, so this makes sense as a first draft for certain use cases. I just wish it were touted as a first draft, rather than a new beautiful finished paradigm.