News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by moe on Monday May 10, 2010 @11:18AM (#1334659)
What value does GS provide in return for those $25MM?

My underlying question would be: Are they a symptom of a systemic flaw (basically a parasite) or does their role in the financial ecosystem somehow justify that kind of profits?

Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by paulitex on Monday May 10, 2010 @11:46AM (#1334744)
Liquidity, mostly.

They are 'market makers'. If you're a big {pension, real estate, rrsp}fund and want to make a trade, say a purchase, you need to call your trader directly. The trader will sell you some of their own (if they have it on their books), or will contact other people who they think may have extra supply on your behalf.

They are the 'grease of the economy'. In theory, it makes markets run smoother, which leads to greater efficiencies for everyone, and makes the world a better place.

(in theory)

Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by mixmax on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:00PM (#1335366)
The thing is that it goes both ways. The liquidity that they provide can just as quickly be pulled back as we saw during the Lehman collapse. I'm not sure it provides value.
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by arijo on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:27PM (#1335475)
Someone has to create the wealth that supports liquidity.
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by cturner on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:42PM (#1335524)
I think you are suggesting that there's something less worthwhile about wealth made via liquidity creation than other forms of wealth.

On that theme - would you say that it is more noble to be a mechanic than programmer, and more noble to be a farmer than a mechanic?

Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by secret on Monday May 10, 2010 @11:45AM (#1334738)
Theoretically, they are finding inefficiencies in the market and eliminating them through a better allocation of capital (and of course profiting from the effort).This is the role of any trader/speculator in a market. Some will be right in their analysis, others wrong, and all known information gets reflected in an asset price. Not having a single down day an an entire quarter basically means that at the end of each day the aggregate of their bets were on the winning side. Given the presumed stochastic nature over small time frames of the markets, that's quite a feat. That said, given the other headlines they've made recently,I strongly emphasize the first word of this reply.
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by martythemaniak on Monday May 10, 2010 @11:38AM (#1334719)
It should be noted it's $25 million profit per day for 63 days, or $1.575 Billion for the quarter. To put it in perspective, that's not very far from Google's quarterly profit (~1.9B)
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by cellis on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:59PM (#1335580)
Yes same stated profit, but they pay half their revenues to their employees. Otherwise their profit would be far higher.
Re:Goldman Sachs Has First Perfect Quarter With Zero Trading... by cturner on Monday May 10, 2010 @11:45AM (#1334739)
A lot of the money they make is on high-speed passive market-making, and they value of this is far tighter spreads on stocks. Compare spreads on the NYSE now to twenty years ago. (Moe, we have to stop meeting like this.)