Re:Jakob Nielsen on iPad Usability: First Findings
by johnrob on Monday May 10, 2010 @05:00PM
(#1335920)
Discoverability on iPhoneOS also suffers from the lack of a mouse pointer, since that takes 'hovering' out of the equation. On the desktop we take for granted the ability to mouseover something to test for clickability (the common case being the mouse arrow turning into a pointing finger when hovering over a link).
Re:Jakob Nielsen on iPad Usability: First Findings
by pook on Monday May 10, 2010 @07:42PM
(#1336272)
Hm. Maybe a "hinting" gesture would work well.
Tap in the upper left corner, and all clickable text/borders becomes distinct (tinted background, etc).
Re:Jakob Nielsen on iPad Usability: First Findings
by moultano on Monday May 10, 2010 @02:19PM
(#1335443)
>Perhaps a pull-up from the bottom for general actions?
Stealing part of the touch screen for consistent app-related behavior really limits what you can do with it I think. The menu button is great ui for games in particular that really need a button to differentiate from all the touching and tapping you'll be doing on the rest of the screen.
With iPod / iPhone / iPad, applications need to be very carefully designed to reveal actions; but every application exposes those actions in slightly different ways. Android, on the other hand, has built-in buttons for Back and Menu, and has a generally common theme of long-press for "context-menu"-like action. This ends up making Apple-platform apps inconsistent, occasionally brilliant but frequently odd, while Android apps are pedestrian but consistently usable, in the sense that actions can easily be discovered and reasonably easily invoked, but not necessarily with a minimum of taps - usually there's at least one or two extra taps involved with Android apps.
I think the optimum would be somewhere in between. Android has too many buttons: the Search button is ironically mostly redundant. The consistency of a back button works really well. The utility of a menu button is debatable; it many ways, it's a cop-out. I wonder if a universal gesture might be more appropriate, a little like the status area of Android is accessed with a pull-down from the top of the screen. Perhaps a pull-up from the bottom for general actions?