Re:Chomsky: Obama should issue a general pardon to undocumen...
by theonemind on Saturday January 07, 2017 @01:47PM
(#13345800)
Can the President do this? The article mentions that pardon power extends beyond criminal offense. However, it doesn't seem clear to me that pardon power covers allowing undocumented immigrants to stay. If, say, I stole $3 million dollars from the US and got pardoned for the crime, they might still want the $3 million back.
I suppose I don't understand the pardon power very well. Could the US illegally deport a citizen, pardon everyone involved, deny the citizen entry, and pardon everyone who conspires to keep the citizen out of the country every time they try to enter? It seems somehow like this, like this use of the pardon power circumvents something more fundamental.
I think the article raises this point somewhere around:
"As we have repeatedly said for years, only Congress can create legal status for undocumented individuals," a White House official told BuzzFeed.
Re:Chomsky: Obama should issue a general pardon to undocumen...
by atomi on Saturday January 07, 2017 @02:26PM
(#13346028)
Doubtful. Unlawful presence is a civil offense and there are no actual criminal proceedings for deportation. In fact you could be accused of unlawful presence without sixth amendment protections.
Re:Chomsky: Obama should issue a general pardon to undocumen...
by detaro on Saturday January 07, 2017 @03:40PM
(#13346493)
Don't pardons also only work for past offenses? Presumably the people for which it is relevant would still be in violation afterwards, which would not be protected by the pardon?
Re:Chomsky: Obama should issue a general pardon to undocumen...
by bratsche on Saturday January 07, 2017 @04:14PM
(#13346679)
Obama was asked about pardoning Edward Snowden (not that long ago I think) and my recollection of his response was that he said he didn't have the power to pardon someone who hadn't yet been convicted of a crime.
Re:Chomsky: Obama should issue a general pardon to undocumen...
by billy8988 on Saturday January 07, 2017 @03:39PM
(#13346480)
If Obama did, I think it will help Trump with his base. Trump can cop out saying he cannot deport 12 million people now ignoring the fact that it is impossible to do.
I suppose I don't understand the pardon power very well. Could the US illegally deport a citizen, pardon everyone involved, deny the citizen entry, and pardon everyone who conspires to keep the citizen out of the country every time they try to enter? It seems somehow like this, like this use of the pardon power circumvents something more fundamental.
I think the article raises this point somewhere around: "As we have repeatedly said for years, only Congress can create legal status for undocumented individuals," a White House official told BuzzFeed.