Re:Why anything? Why this? (1998)
by mannykannot on Saturday January 07, 2017 @08:13AM
(#13343973)
Are you not conflating 'things that make problems tractable' with 'things that must be'?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I don't see how. Firstly, Kolmogorov complexity is incomputable, so it's not technically tractable, it's merely an idealised induction process.
Secondly, assigning a higher probability to an outcome isn't saying that how things are.
Re:Why anything? Why this? (1998)
by mannykannot on Saturday January 07, 2017 @05:14PM
(#13346957)
Correspondingly, no claim about the likelihood of an infinite hierarchy of functions is saying how things are.
Which I didn't say, I simply said it was unlikely. In fact, vanishingly unlikely because it relies on infinity.
Re:Why anything? Why this? (1998)
by mannykannot on Sunday January 08, 2017 @09:51AM
(#13349871)
You might not have written it in exactly those words, but the corollary of your observation still holds.
Saying that an infinite hierarchy of functions is unlikely is saying that we probably don't live in a world governed by an infinite hierarchy of functions. But that's all it says, and as I pointed out, we have good a priori reasons for believing this conclusion, without having to ontologically commit ourselves to accepting it as necessarily true.
So I disagree, it's still not conflating "things that are likely" with "things that are".