News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jimbo Wales exiles 'porn' from Wikiland by ugh on Monday May 10, 2010 @08:26AM (#1334177)
The big problem with any centralized deletion of porn is that there is no standard definition of porn. Commons should strive to only exclude images which can lead to legal problems and leave the decision which of the remaining images to use up to the different language Wikipedias.

Maybe that’s what they plan to do and I would have no problem with that. I would have a problem if they went above and beyond that.

Re:Jimbo Wales exiles 'porn' from Wikiland by buro9 on Monday May 10, 2010 @09:16AM (#1334303)
Even that would be a problem... legal problems according to what legal domain? What is acceptable in some US States is wildly different from what is acceptable in some EU countries.

The concern I have is greater than the definition of what is or is not pornographic, but it is the underlying notion that some entity feels that I should not see something, that a puritanical approach has come in at the top. To me this is the greater problem.

If we stick to legal definitions then we're in a much better position, even though the lack of a global legal system introduces technical issues about what is stored where, and what is available to whom (according to where they are) and the maintenance of that legal knowledge (that in one region the laws are X, Y and Z and that in another the laws are B, C and D).