How about the number three? Does it exist? Or the square root of 2? I can't touch it, that's for sure.
People don't want infinity per se. We want a number system where you can do nice things to numbers and get out other numbers... and have nice theorems like "a continuous graph that goes from negative to positive must cross the zero line somewhere"... and then it turns out that the number system that fulfills our need consists of infinite sequences of digits, and finite sequences won't suffice.
I said, quite clearly, "I understand that mathematics isn't simply about physical phenomenon. I understand the beauty of i, for example."
You mention 3 and the square root of 2. You plug both of those in to: (x == x+1) and you'll get an inequality. Not so with infinity.
Again, Rider has set me straight that I need to learn more. I can believe that, but when I see how often in the physical world we creep up on infinity only to have it not exist, I'm definitely skeptical about plugging in infinity into equations like x == x + 1. It seems it doesn't make any sense at all.
Allow me to illustrate. Take the following problem stated in school geometry terms: A square is cut into triangles of equal area, now prove that their number is even. Interestingly, we don't yet know any elementary solution to this problem that can be stated in school math terms. The only solution known was discovered in the 1970s and relies on something called "p-adic numbers". What are those p-adic numbers you ask? They are weird number-like things that have infinitely many digits to the left of the decimal point. Freaky constructs without any counterpart in the real world, but you can still add them, multiply them and all that. Do such things "really exist"? Don't know, don't care. But they helped us solve a difficult problem and that's all that matters.
Edit: but that still seems to me to reflect infinitely, the adjective, as opposed to infinity, the noun. Still, thanks.
Hilbert's hotel is more of a set-theory problem than a calculus or geometry problem, so it's best to think of the set of rooms having infinite cardinality. A set of countably infinite cardinality (the guests) is of the same cardinality when another (finite or) countably infinte set is added, so we can develop a one-to-one correspondence between it and another set of countably infinite cardinality (the rooms). Thinking about it this way demystifies the problem a little.
Not knowing that there is an unlimited number of numbers becomes a problem. Trying to do any math without allowing that between any two numbers there's another number is pretty difficult.
There are people who derive a mathematics without the axiom of infinity, but it's weird, distorted, unnatural and doesn't turn out to be as useful as often as the regular variety of math.
Feel free not to believe. Just don't expect to do much advanced math.
Oh, and if you use proof techniques in programming, such as loop invariants or transformation theory, you are using infinity, you just didn't realise it.
I have no problem with the concept of infinity in terms of limits, but that's not what this article is about. It's about the concept of infinity itself. And that is what I disagree with.
Because, in part, you can't have the one without the other. You can't talk about limits without having a model for infinity. They are inextricably entwined, each idea leading to the other.
It's sounds to me like you've simply been put off by loads of badly written Pop-Math articles that attempt to boggle and astound, without showing the real truths as to why the whole subject is really, really cool, and simultaneously, useful and practical.
Brian Clegg's book on infinity gets good reviews, but I haven't read it. I'm thinking of starting a blog series on it, but with everything else I have on I may never really get to it.
But as I say, in your specific case it really depends on your background. If you're really interested perhaps you could email me more details on what you've studied and what you've read, and I can write some brief articles by way of reply.
or its even stricter cousin, which not only denies the meaningful existence of infinity, but also the meaningful existence of technically finite but infeasibly large numbers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultrafinitism
That said, I will point out that math is essentially a game played by certain rules known as "axioms", and there is no one true set of axioms. If you choose one set, you get infinity; if you choose another, you don't (but you will pay for that). You can't say which is "more right" or "more wrong" without bringing other subjective standards into it, each of which may have their own utility. While "corresponds to the physical universe" is definitely one useful such standard, it is still not the only one.
Do read up on the limits of computable numbers though; they are interesting, but it's not a free lunch.
Maybe for you, maybe not for someone who enjoys doing it.
Imagine defining a function in terms of itself! That's circular and you can always get away with just using a loop instead.
Well, it turns out recursion often works and is very useful. Just like infinity.
I meant infinity, not the limit of infinity.
I have no problem with the concept of infinity in terms of limits, but that's not what this article is about. It's about the concept of infinity itself. And that is what I disagree with.
It's playing around at the limits of human reason. I don't see it as any different to most sports, music, and art. All are appreciated by different groups of people but, ultimately, "useless" if you do not value the enjoyment gained from exploration for its own sake.
Every time we expect something infinite in physical phenomenon, it turns out to have some sort of Plank-like constant that compartmentalizes the effect at different levels to avoid that result.
Which is good, because a universe where infinity existed would most likely not be stable enough to support life. I understand that mathematics isn't simply about physical phenomenon. I understand the beauty of i, for example. But I think that screwing around with the bizarre aspects of a concept like infinity is a huge waste of time.