Well it can't obviously, but lots of people (although maybe not the types of people who use tor) browse the internet with their speakers on and active. Most people don't unmute their speakers just before they're about to listen to something.
> How do they bypass the little sound notification on my tabs?
Admittedly they probably can't, but are you sure you're going to notice a flicker as a short sound is played and then stops?
I think the most contrived part is your mobile being always-on/always listening, given that you're likely to notice this due to reduced battery life. But given that certain hardware now has support for always-on keyword detection, you can see a future when this could happen.
Either way, it doesn't sound like that's what the article describes: they're talking about collecting and sending all audio wholesale. Sending that much audio data over 3g or LTE would be expensive (transcoding it to decrease payload would be expensive, too), and would surely be noticeable looking at data usage charts.
> using wi-fi, there was no data plan spike
Uh, yeah. Because it's using wifi. Phones are on wifi far less often than you'd imagine.
It's certainly possible, but it's just not plausible.
Having said that, quite a few people have their phones connected to wifi at home, which could mitigate these issues due to both less conspicuous data and power usage.
Even if it was the case, I can't imagine such apps would give granular enough information to be enormously useful. You'd get one, maybe two people to actually get their computers to play the audio and have it picked up by a device that's actually listening for it. What then? How many advertising companies with legitimate marketing businesses actually sell the user identities? You'd get what, a UUID, maybe some aggregate demographic information, and a rough location. It seems unlikely that such a platform would actually give out specific PII for individuals.
It would not need to be constantly listening for it to be useful. If the point is identification, why would you leave it on after you have reasonably identified the person?
If we assume it's a third-party ad network, which is the only plausible explanation for why there's an app listening for ultrasonic cues on a user's device, it would need to be listening all the time. That is what the article describes.
>If the Tor user has his phone somewhere nearby and if certain types of apps are on his phone, then his mobile device will ping back one or more advertisers with details about his device, so the advertiser can build an advertising profile on the user, linking his computer with his phone.
This is pretty contrived...