Re:Compute Card, a Credit Card-Sized Compute Platform
by astrodust on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:50PM
(#13333760)
I'm starting to wonder if next-generation blade systems might not just have a bunch of USB-C connectors to act as a backplane. They provide power, data connectivity, external storage links and anything more. Small, self-contained modules like this could contain the CPU and whatever other components are best to have locally, like a small local SSD and memory.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Compute Card, a Credit Card-Sized Compute Platform
by detaro on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:52PM
(#13333773)
For blades I would expect mostly PCIe lanes to the outside. USB-C IMHO adds a lot of extras that are not needed for that use case.
Re:Compute Card, a Credit Card-Sized Compute Platform
by astrodust on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:53PM
(#13333776)
USB-C/TB can carry PCIe lanes, so it's mostly a matter of latency due to protocol overhead more than bandwidth.
Re:Compute Card, a Credit Card-Sized Compute Platform
by detaro on Thursday January 05, 2017 @10:57PM
(#13333798)
Sure, but why would you add that overhead (both in latency and electronics needed) to transport e.g. 16 PCIe lanes over 4 USB connections just to then direct it to PCIe devices anyways, especially if those devices partially need more than 4 lanes?
USB-C is a really cool solution, but a solution for the needs of laptops/other personal devices, not servers.
Re:Compute Card, a Credit Card-Sized Compute Platform
by astrodust on Saturday January 07, 2017 @03:40AM
(#13343040)
Why would you add the overhead?
* Dead simple design. * Easily hot-swappable without expensive proprietary connectors. * Low cost solution that provides adequate bandwidth.
This isn't something that will perform better than a proper server with actual PCIe lanes, but it will perform better than a blade from two generations ago that didn't have that kind of backplane bandwidth and it will cost less to manufacture.